Assessing clinical reasoning skills using Script Concordance Test (SCT) and extended matching questions (EMQs): A pilot for urology trainees

Authors

  • JAMSHEER TALATI Section of Urology, Department of Surgery, The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan.
  • JOHN NORCINI Foundation for Advancement of International Medical Education and Research (FAIMER), Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States of America
  • MUHAMMAD ATHER Section of Urology, Department of Surgery, The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan
  • SHEILA PINJANI Department for Educational development, The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan
  • SYED NAZIM 1Section of Urology, Department of Surgery, The Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan
Abstract:

Introduction: Clinical reasoning skill is the core of medicalcompetence. Commonly used assessment methods for medicalcompetence have limited ability to evaluate critical thinking andreasoning skills. Script Concordance Test (SCT) and ExtendedMatching Questions (EMQs) are the evolving tests which areconsidered to be valid and reliable tools for assessing clinicalreasoning and judgment. We performed this pilot study to determinewhether SCT and EMQs can differentiate clinical reasoning abilityamong urology residents, interns and medical students.Methods: This was a cross-sectional study in which an examinationwith 48 SCT-based items on eleven clinical scenarios and four themedEMQs with 21 items were administered to a total of 27 learners atthree differing levels of experience i.e. 9 urology residents, 6 internsand 12 fifth year medical students. A non-probability conveniencesampling was done. The SCTs and EMQs were developed fromclinical situations representative of urological practice by 5 contentexperts (urologists) and assessed by a medical education expert.Learners’ responses were scored using the standard and the graduatedkey. A one way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was conducted tocompare the mean scores across the level of experience. A p-valueof

Upgrade to premium to download articles

Sign up to access the full text

Already have an account?login

similar resources

Assessing clinical reasoning in optometry using the script concordance test.

BACKGROUND Clinical reasoning is central to any health profession but its development among learners is difficult to assess. Over the last few decades, the script concordance test (SCT) has been developed to solve this dilemma and has been used in many health professions; however, no study has been published on the use of the script concordance test in optometry. The purpose of this study was t...

full text

Using the script concordance test to assess clinical reasoning skills in undergraduate and postgraduate medicine.

The script concordance test is a relatively new format of written assessment that is used to assess higher-order clinical reasoning and data interpretation skills in medicine. Candidates are presented with a clinical scenario, followed by the reveal of a new piece of information. The candidates are then asked to assess whether this additional information increases or decreases the probability o...

full text

On line clinical reasoning assessment with Script Concordance test in urology: results of a French pilot study

BACKGROUND The Script Concordance test (SC) test is an assessment tool that measures the capacity to solve ill-defined problems, that is, reasoning in a context of uncertainty. This study assesses the feasibility, reliability and validity of the SC test made available on the Web to French urologists. METHODS A 97 items SC test was developed based on major educational objectives of French urol...

full text

The Script Concordance Test in anesthesiology: Validation of a new tool for assessing clinical reasoning.

OBJECTIVE To evaluate whether the Script Concordance Test (SCT) can discriminate between levels of experience among anesthesiology residents and attending physicians. STUDY TYPE Multicenter (Toulouse, Nantes, Bordeaux and Limoges), prospective, observational study. PATIENTS AND METHODS A SCT made of 60 items was used to evaluate "junior residents" (n=60), "senior residents" (n=47) and exper...

full text

Assessing clinical reasoning in pediatric emergency medicine: validity evidence for a Script Concordance Test.

STUDY OBJECTIVE Clinical reasoning is a crucial skill for all residents to acquire during their training. During most patient encounters in pediatric emergency medicine, physicians and trainees are challenged by diagnostic, investigative, and treatment uncertainties. The Script Concordance Test may provide a means to assess reasoning skills in the context of uncertainty in the practice of pedia...

full text

Assessing clinical reasoning in anesthesiology: Making the case for the Script Concordance Test.

Whether our field of expertise is providing anesthesia per se, perioperative medicine, critical care or pain management, as physicians and healthcare professionals most of us need to display and rely on our clinical reasoning skills on a daily basis. Although there is no unanimously accepted way to define clinical reasoning, most experts would probably agree that, at the minimum, it encompasses...

full text

My Resources

Save resource for easier access later

Save to my library Already added to my library

{@ msg_add @}


Journal title

volume 7  issue 1

pages  7- 13

publication date 2019-01-01

By following a journal you will be notified via email when a new issue of this journal is published.

Keywords

Hosted on Doprax cloud platform doprax.com

copyright © 2015-2023