A revealed-preference theory of strategic counterfactuals
نویسنده
چکیده
The analysis of extensive-form games involves assumptions concerning players’ beliefs at histories off the predicted path of play. However, the revealed-preference interpretation of such assumptions is unclear: how does one elicit probabilities conditional upon events that have zero ex-ante probability? This paper addresses this issue by proposing and axiomatizing a novel choice criterion for an individual who faces a general dynamic decision problem. The individual’s preferences are characterized by a Bernoulli utility function and a conditional probability system Myerson (1986a). At any decision point, preferences are determined by conditional expected payoffs at the current node, as well as at all subsequent nodes. Thus, prior preferences contain enough information to identify all conditional beliefs. Furthermore, preferences are dynamically consistent, so prior preferences also determine behavior at subsequent decision nodes, including those that have zero ex-ante probability. In particular, the proposed criterion is consistent with, and indeed inspired by the game-theoretic notion of sequential rationality. ∗Economics Department, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208; [email protected]. I thank Amanda Friedenberg and participants at RUD 2011 for helpful comments on an early draft of this paper.
منابع مشابه
Strategic Evaluation of Sustainable Projects based on Hybrid Group Decision Analysis with Incomplete Information
– Sustainable evaluation of construction projects in strategy-focused condition is the main issue for municipalities to appropriately improve public sector services. In this respect, the group decision-making methods could help experts to select suitable sustainable projects and to schedule them regarding their ranking results. Therefore, the objective of this study is to present a hybrid group...
متن کاملAn application of logarithmic fuzzy preference programming-based AHP and FRS techniques to develop and prioritize strategic objectives
Vital decisions made at the strategic level in an organization are not only intricate but also costly to alter. It is therefore important to find a comprehensive approach to deal with such a possibility. One of the major problems of a common balanced scorecard (BSC)-based model in strategic management is lack of a ranking system for strategic objectives in order to enable prioritization of the ...
متن کاملCommunity-Based Reasoning in Games: Salience, Rule-Following, and Counterfactuals
This paper develops a game-theoretic and epistemic account of a peculiar mode of practical reasoning that sustains focal points but also more general forms of rule-following behavior which I call community-based reasoning (CBR). It emphasizes the importance of counterfactuals in strategic interactions. In particular, the existence of rules does not reduce to observable behavioral patterns but a...
متن کاملTime-Symmetrized Counterfactuals in Quantum Theory
Counterfactuals in quantum theory are briefly reviewed and it is argued that they are very different from counterfactuals considered in the general philosophical literature. The issue of time symmetry of quantum counterfactuals is considered and a novel time-symmetric definition of quantum counterfactuals is proposed. This definition is applied for analyzing several controversies related to qua...
متن کاملCREDIBILITY THEORY ORIENTED PREFERENCE INDEX FOR RANKING FUZZY NUMBERS
This paper suggests a novel approach for ranking the most applicable fuzzy numbers, i.e. $LR$-fuzzy numbers. Applying the $alpha$-optimistic values of a fuzzy number, a preference criterion is proposed for ranking fuzzy numbers using the Credibility index. The main properties of the proposed preference criterion are also studied. Moreover, the proposed method is applied for ranking fuzz...
متن کامل