Revisiting the distinction between accomplishments and achievements
نویسندگان
چکیده
As is well known, Vendler (1957) proposed to distinguish between two classes of telic predicates, namely, accomplishments (eat an apple, draw a circle), denoting durative events, and achievements (reach the summit, win the race), denoting punctual ones. As Kearns (2003) has recently emphasized, Vendler adopted this distinction from Ryle (1949), who already distinguished « task verbs » like search or participate, which denote an action, and « achievement verbs » or « failure verbs » like find or lose, which denote a possible achievement (or failure) obtained through this action. The term achievement suggests by itself that Ryle's distinction is not merely a temporal one, as Vendler's one is. As is well known too, the distinction between accomplishments and achievements has been criticized for several reasons. A first counterargument is proposed by Verkuyl (1972), and developed further by Egg (1995). According to them, punctuality is an extra-linguistic property of situations, not a linguistic feature. To repeat one of Verkuyl's example, draw a circle denotes a durative event if the circle is drawn with a pencil, but can arguably denote a punctual one if it is drawn with a computer. Hence, this predicate cannot be assigned a value for the punctuality feature in its semantics. Several authors have provided strong arguments in defense of the original Vendlerian distinction, and, in particular, against this first counterargument. Pursuing an intuition of Freed (1979) and Mittwoch (1990), Piñón (1997) rejects the definition of punctual events denoted by achievements as « very short » events, and take them literally as events without any duration. Under this second definition, events denoted by achievements are not « instantaneous » in the same sense than flashings or
منابع مشابه
The Relationship between Time Management and Academic Achievements Among Bachelor and Master Students of Shiraz University and Shiraz University of Medical Sciences
Introduction: The capability of applying time management skill, is an important factor in academic and non-academic achievements. This study was performed to investigate the relationship between time management and academic achievement of master and bachelor students of Shiraz University (SU) and Shiraz University of Medical Sciences (SUMS). Methods: In this descriptive cross sectional study, 6...
متن کاملComputational Lexical Semantics, Incrementality, and the So-called Punctuality of Events
The distinction between achievements and accomplishments is known to be an empirically important but subtle one. It is argued here to depend on the atomicity (rather than punctuality) of events, and to be strongly related to incrementality (i.e., to event-object mapping functions). A computational treatment of incrementality and atomicity is discussed in the paper, and a number of related empir...
متن کاملRevisiting Jacques Greber's L'Architecture aux Etats-Unis: from city beautiful to cité-jardin.
In 1920, Jacques Gréber published what was and still is the largest book on U.S. architecture and urban design ever issued in France. His dual agenda was to stress the impact of Beaux-Arts design methods (presenting his gardens and Philadelphia parkway as highlights of this trend), and to advocate the practical accomplishments of a pragmatic and affluent civilization. Showcasing an "edited" Nor...
متن کاملTelicity in L2 Chinese Acquisition
The interaction between syntactic structures and event structures has become an important area of linguistic research. The telic/atelic distinction, a property of an event having or not having a natural endpoint, is a focus in the discussion of this interaction. Together with durativity and dynamicity, telicity, a semantic notion, forms the base of the well-known Vendler (1967) four-way typolog...
متن کامل