De Broglie-Bohm Pilot-Wave Theory: Many Worlds in Denial?
نویسنده
چکیده
We reply to claims (by Deutsch, Zeh, Brown and Wallace) that the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm is really a many-worlds theory with a superfluous configuration appended to one of the worlds. Assuming that pilot-wave theory does contain an ontological pilot wave (a complex-valued field in configuration space), we show that such claims arise from not interpreting pilot-wave theory on its own terms. Specifically, the theory has its own (‘subquantum’) theory of measurement, and in general describes a ‘nonequilibrium’ state that violates the Born rule. Furthermore, in realistic models of the classical limit, one does not obtain localised pieces of an ontological pilot wave following alternative macroscopic trajectories: from a de Broglie-Bohm viewpoint, alternative trajectories are merely mathematical and not ontological. Thus, from the perspective of pilot-wave theory itself, many worlds are an illusion. It is further argued that, even leaving pilot-wave theory aside, the theory of many worlds is rooted in the intrinsically unlikely assumption that quantum measurements should be modelled on classical measurements, and is therefore unlikely to be true.
منابع مشابه
9 J an 2 00 9 Comment on Valentini , “ De Broglie - Bohm Pilot - Wave Theory : Many Worlds in Denial ? ”
Valentini has recently defended the de Broglie-Bohm pilot-wave version of quantum theory from the claim that it is essentially Everett theory encumbered with the redundant postulation of point particles. In this note, Valentini’s central arguments are questioned.
متن کاملar X iv : 0 81 1 . 08 10 v 1 [ qu an t - ph ] 5 N ov 2 00 8 De Broglie - Bohm Pilot - Wave Theory : Many Worlds in Denial ?
We reply to claims (by Deutsch, Zeh, Brown andWallace) that the pilot-wave theory of de Broglie and Bohm is really a many-worlds theory with a superfluous configuration appended to one of the worlds. Assuming that pilot-wave theory does contain an ontological pilot wave (a complex-valued field in configuration space), we show that such claims arise from not interpreting pilot-wave theory on its...
متن کاملThe Classical Limit of Bohmian Mechanics: Semiclassical Wave Packets and an Application to Many Particle Scattering Theory
متن کامل
An Exceptionally Simple Argument Against the Many-worlds Interpretation: Further Consolidations
It is argued that the components of the superposed wave function of a measuring device, each of which represents a definite measurement result, do not correspond to many worlds, one of which is our world, because all components of the wave function can be measured in our world by a serious of protective measurements, and they all exist in this world. In standard quantum mechanics, it is postula...
متن کاملBohmian Conditional Wave Functions (and the status of the quantum state)
The de Broglie Bohm pilot-wave theory – uniquely among realistic candidate quantum theories – allows a straightforward and simple definition of the wave function of a subsystem of some larger system (such as the entire universe). Such sub-system wave functions are called “Conditional Wave Functions” (CWFs). Here we explain this concept and indicate the CWF’s role in the Bohmian explanation of t...
متن کامل