Mind – Body – Spirituality
نویسنده
چکیده
The argument of this paper is that the modern brain-consciousness debate has left out one important element: the question of a transpersonal or spirit-like element of consciousness. Thus the problem really is not a mind-body-problem or brain-consciousness problem, but a mind-body-spirit or brain-consciousness-soul problem. Looking at the history of the debate it can be seen that, explicitly or implicitly, this aspect has always been part of the philosophical debate. Most notably, this can be seen in the Aristotelian concept of the soul, which held that form and matter were both together necessary to constitute a unity. But on top of that, a Platonic strand of teaching existed in Aristotle, which was lost. This tradition stipulated an aspect of the soul, the active intellect, that was separate and separable. This idea has inspired other and later writers into postulating an immortal part of the soul. In the modern debate this tradition has been lost and was frequently amalgamated with dualist positions. Phenomenological descriptions of mystical experiences, as well as other unusual (or exceptional) mind-matter anomalies suggest that this aspect of the problem needs reconsideration. For this purpose a transcendental kind of monism is suggested which does not violate the consensus that only a monist description of the world is scientifically viable. Such a position would, in addition, provide the option to incorporate the transpersonal side of the debate. 1. Distinguishing Personal and Transpersonal Views It is suggested that there are two essentially different aspects of the mind-body problem: (a) There is the brain-consciousness or traditional mind-body problem. It is addressed by asking questions like: Can the phenomenal qualities which characterize our experience of “mind” be reduced to the physical qualities of patterned neuron-discharges ? Is the brain alone sufficient to give rise to personal consciousness, or do we need a separate entity ? Is consciousness a “real”, non-reducible entity which nevertheless is completely causally dependent or supervenient on
منابع مشابه
The witches' brew of spirituality and medicine.
Recent proposals to join spirituality and medicine are facile and ill defined. The notion that physicians have the time or training to make assessments and recommendations about spirituality is misguided. Whenever a physician demonstrates personal caring for a patient, the healing process is likely enhanced, and in that sense, physicians often promote the spirituality of the patient. However, r...
متن کاملMeditation and Brain Activity from the Bioscience- Bioethical Perspective
Spirituality draws people to places of worship, prayer, meditation, sacred dance, mountain tops or other inspirational activity. Some of us find spirituality through religion; others find it through science, music, art or a connection with Nature, while still others find it in their personal values and principles. No matter how it’s defined, this elusive entity describes the way we find meaning...
متن کاملUnderstanding Spiritual Awareness in Terms of Anomalous Information Access
In this paper I identify a link between the problem of explaining anomalous access to information (‘psi’ or ‘psychic ability’) and the problem of giving an account of the nature of consciousness (‘the mind-body problem’). I argue that progress with understanding psi requires selecting a suitable ontological model for dealing with the mind-body problem. I review alternatives and argue, on philos...
متن کاملBody Responsiveness Questionnaire: Validation on a European sample, Mediation between Body Awareness and Affect, connection with Mindfulness, Body Image, and Physical Activity
Body responsiveness is ‘the tendency to integrate body sensations into conscious awareness to guide decision making and behavior and not suppress or react impulsively to them’. It is assessed by a 7-item tool, the Body Responsiveness Questionnaire (BRQ), which has not yet been validated on the European population. We aimed to translate the original version of Daubenmier’s BRQ, and test its cons...
متن کاملSpirituality in medical practice.
Body, mind, and spirit are integrally connected. Medical training in the Western world has been strong concerning the more easily measured physical aspects, and on the mental needs it has been virtually mute on how to minister to the spiritual needs of our patients. Learning the spiritual aspects of medical care is not a typical part of the medical school curriculum, and yet it is emerging as s...
متن کامل