John Perry’s neglected critique of Kelvin’s age for the Earth: A missed opportunity in geodynamics
نویسندگان
چکیده
Many readers know the tale of how William Thomson (later Lord Kelvin) calculated the age of the Earth from physical principles and adhered for over 50 years to an estimate that was far younger than geologists’ estimates, despite the virtually unanimous opposition of the geological community of the time. The prevalent version of this tale alleges that the discovery of radioactivity simultaneously provided the demonstration (through radiometric dating) that Kelvin had greatly underestimated the age of the Earth and the explanation of why he was wrong (radioactivity being a source of heat that invalidated Kelvin’s calculation). We show this popular story to be incorrect; introducing the known distribution of radioactivity into Kelvin’s calculation does not invalidate its conclusion. In 1895, before the discovery of radioactivity, John Perry showed that convection in the Earth’s interior would invalidate Kelvin’s estimate for the age of the Earth, but Perry’s analysis was neglected or forgotten, with the consequence that a powerful argument in favor of mobilism was overlooked during the first few decades of debate about continental drift.
منابع مشابه
Murtahda Mutahhari and John Stuart Mill's Critique of the Consumeristic Commodification of Culture
متن کامل
A critique of the scientific interpretation of »the seven heavens and of the earth« in the Qur`an
Abstract The subject of the seven heavens and of the earth in the verse of the twelve, surah Talaq has been of the controversial problems among the commentators. Some commentators that consider scientific method, have adjusted this verse on celestial spheres and seven climates. It seems that this kind of unfair conformity, which is rooted in scientism, not only does not help to solve the prob...
متن کاملتأثیر میزوپروستول واژینال در درمان سقط فراموش شده
Introduction: Missed Abortion is a important obstetric and gynecology complication because of its serious outcomes such as DIC, infection, shock, hemorrhage & death. There are various medical and surgical methods for treatment of missed abortion. Medical treatment of missed abortion is safe, effective, acceptable and an inexpensive alternative. Misoprostal is a synthetic prostaglandin (E1) and ...
متن کاملGround deformation in the Taupo Volcanic Zone, New Zealand, observed by ALOS PALSAR interferometry
Sergey Samsonov,1,2 John Beavan,1 Pablo J. González,3 Kristy Tiampo3 and José Fernández4,5 1GNS Science, Lower Hutt, New Zealand. E-mail: [email protected] 2European Center for Geodynamics and Seismology, Walferdange, Grand-Duchy of Luxembourg 3Department of Earth Sciences, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada 4Instituto de Astronomia y Geodesia (CSIC-UCM), Fac. C. Matematicas, M...
متن کاملHiatal Hernia as a Mysterious Diagnosis; a Case Report
Introduction: Proximal displacement of stomach and gastro-esophageal junction into the thoracic cavity results in a condition known as hiatal hernia (HH). Sometimes this entity is neglected in practice and the patient is handled as gastroesophageal reflux disease, asthma or other non-surgical diagnosis.Case: Here we present a 6 months-old female infant who present with bloody emesis since two m...
متن کامل