Subject islands and the Subject Criterion VALENTINA BIANCHI CRISTIANO CHESI
نویسندگان
چکیده
Subject island effects are variable and unstable. Previous accounts, relying on well-defined structural properties of subjects, fail to capture this variability. We argue that subjects are islands only when they satisfy the Subject Criterion, which implies that at the interface they are interpreted outside the predicative nucleus of the clause, in a categorical structure (à la Ladusaw 1994); on the contrary, they are transparent for extraction when they undergo total reconstruction into the predicative nucleus of the clause, giving rise to a thetic structure. The thetic vs. categorical interpretation correlates with (non)presuppositionality and it is constrained by various factors, most notably the stage-level vs. individual-level nature of the predicate: this interaction of different factors can account for the observed variability, and is supported by our experimental evidence. The transparency of totally reconstructed subjects is not stipulated, but is shown to fall out from a top-down oriented syntactic computation, as proposed in Chesi (2004).
منابع مشابه
Subject islands and the Subject Criterion VALENTINA BIANCHI CRISTIANO
Subject island effects are variable and unstable. Previous accounts, relying on well-defined structural properties of subjects, fail to capture this variability. We argue that subjects are islands only when they satisfy the Subject Criterion, which implies that at the interface they are interpreted outside the predicative nucleus of the clause, in a categorical structure (à la Ladusaw 1994); on...
متن کاملPhases, Left Branch Islands, and Computational Nesting
In this paper we reconsider the connectedness effect discussed by Kayne (1983), and illustrated in the examples (1)-(3). Kayne observed that in VO languages, left branch constituents are strong islands for extraction; however, an illegitimate gap inside a left branch island can be rescued by another gap embedded in a lower right branch constituent. The examples in (1)-(2) illustrate preverbal s...
متن کاملPhases, Strong Islands, and Computational Nesting
In this paper we reconsider the connectedness effect discussed by Kayne (1983), and illustrated in the examples (1)-(3). Kayne observed that in VO languages, left branch constituents are strong islands for extraction; however, an illegitimate gap inside a left branch island can be rescued by another gap embedded in a lower right branch constituent. The examples in (1)-(2) illustrate preverbal s...
متن کاملIntroduction to directionality
Studies in linguistics (Centro interdipartimentale di studi cognitivi sul linguaggio)
متن کامل