Valuing Laws as Local Amenities
نویسنده
چکیده
The conventional approach to evaluating a law is to examine its effect on proximate behavior. To evaluate a new criminal law, for example, the conventional approach would look to changes in the crime rate. This paper argues instead that laws should be judged by the extent to which they raise housing prices and lower wages. The logic is that the value of a law, much like the value of a lake or a public school, is capitalized into local housing and labor markets. Desirable laws increase housing prices and decrease wages because more people want to live in the relevant jurisdiction; undesirable laws have the opposite effects. Evaluating laws in the manner has several advantages over the conventional approach. First, it employs a more direct proxy for utility. Second, it accounts for all the effects of a law, including hard-to-measure outcomes, unintended consequences, and enforcement costs. Third, it permits direct comparison of different types of laws, which is important in instances where law-makers have limited resources to invest in law-making. Lastly, it sheds light on the distributional consequences of a law. In particular, it makes clear that a significant portion of every law’s benefits are reallocated through housing and labor markets to property owners.
منابع مشابه
Valuing the Consumption Benefits of Urban Density
Despite growing interest in urban consumption amenities, little is known about their origin and importance. This paper estimates the consumption value of urban density by combining travel microdata with Google’s local business data. This dataset allows to integrate travel costs into a discrete choice model for restaurants. I find that in high density areas, consumers enjoy large benefits from v...
متن کاملEstimating the economic value of cultural ecosystem services in an urbanizing area using hedonic pricing.
A need exists to increase both knowledge and recognition of the values associated with ecosystem services and amenities. This article explores the use of hedonic pricing as a tool for eliciting these values. We take a case study approach, valuing several services provided by ecosystems, namely aesthetic quality (views), access to outdoor recreation, and the benefits provided by tree cover in Da...
متن کاملDo residents’ perceptions of being well-placed and objective presence of local amenities match? A case study in West Central Scotland, UK
BACKGROUND Recently there has been growing interest in how neighbourhood features, such as the provision of local facilities and amenities, influence residents' health and well-being. Prior research has measured amenity provision through subjective measures (surveying residents' perceptions) or objective (GIS mapping of distance) methods. The latter may provide a more accurate measure of physic...
متن کاملBuying Into Bohemia: the Impact of Cultural Amenities on Property Values
Communities in both Europe and North America are encouraging the development of cultural amenities as a strategy for improving quality of life, attracting and retaining productive workers, and promoting urban revitalization. If these policies are effective then the presence of cultural amenities should increase the local demand for housing, and the value of cultural amenities should be reflecte...
متن کامل