Reasons for Hardness in Quantified Boolean Formulas
نویسندگان
چکیده
We aim to understand inherent reasons for lower bounds for QBF proof systems, and revisit and compare two previous approaches in this direction. The first of these relates size lower bounds for strong QBF Frege systems to circuit lower bounds via strategy extraction (Beyersdorff & Pich, LICS’16). Here we show a refined version of strategy extraction and thereby for any QBF proof system obtain a trichotomy for hardness: (1) via circuit lower bounds, (2) via propositional Resolution lower bounds, or (3) ‘genuine’ QBF lower bounds. The second approach tries to explain QBF lower bounds through quantifier alternations in a system called relaxing QU-Res (Chen, ICALP’16). We prove a strong lower bound for relaxing QU-Res, which at the same time exhibits significant shortcomings of that model. Prompted by this we propose an alternative, improved version, allowing more flexible oracle queries in proofs. We show that lower bounds in our new model correspond to the trichotomy obtained via strategy extraction.
منابع مشابه
Treewidth: A Useful Marker of Empirical Hardness in Quantified Boolean Logic Encodings
Theoretical studies show that in some combinatorial problems, there is a close relationship between classes of tractable instances and the treewidth (tw) of graphs describing their structure. In the case of satisfiability for quantified Boolean formulas (QBFs), tractable classes can be related to a generalization of treewidth, that we call quantified treewidth (twp). In this paper we investigat...
متن کاملFormulas with Large Weight: a New Technique for Genuine QBF Lower Bounds
We devise a new technique to prove lower bounds for the proof size in resolutiontype calculi for quantified Boolean formulas (QBF). The new technique applies to the strong expansion system IR-calc and thereby also to the most studied QBF system Q-Resolution. Our technique exploits a clear semantic paradigm, showing the hardness of a QBF family by demonstrating that (1) the formulas require larg...
متن کاملAn Alternative Representation for QBF
Quantified Boolean formulas are a powerful representation that have been used to capture and solve a variety of problems in Artificial Intelligence. While most research has focused on quantified Boolean formulas in prenex normal form (QBF), we explore an alternative representation of quantified Boolean formulas, called Constrained Quantified Formulas (CQF). CQF allows for a more direct represen...
متن کاملProof Complexity of Resolution-based QBF Calculi
Proof systems for quantified Boolean formulas (QBFs) provide a theoretical underpinning for the performance of important QBF solvers. However, the proof complexity of these proof systems is currently not well understood and in particular lower bound techniques are missing. In this paper we exhibit a new and elegant proof technique for showing lower bounds in QBF proof systems based on strategy ...
متن کاملThe Second QBF Solvers Comparative Evaluation
This paper reports about the 2004 comparative evaluation of solvers for quantified Boolean formulas (QBFs), the second in a series of non-competitive events established with the aim of assessing the advancements in the field of QBF reasoning and related research. We evaluated sixteen solvers on a test set of about one thousand benchmarks, selected from instances submitted to the evaluation and ...
متن کامل