Quine’s Ideological Debacle
نویسندگان
چکیده
In two papers in the mid-seventies, Quine has discussed an ontological debacle, the reduction of ontology to an ontology of pure sets only. This debacle, which weakened Quine’s interest in ontology, is the natural outcome of ontological relativity, or, more precisely, the proxy-function argument. It is explained how Quine unavoidably came to this conclusion. Moreover, it is argued that the result is even more damaging for Quine’s philosophy than has hitherto been assumed. It is shown that in addition to an ontological debacle, there is an ideological debacle, reducing the ideology (lexicon) of science to the ideology of set theory. The ideological debacle results from applying extensional substitution of predicates within a scientific theory that is reinterpreted by means of proxy-functions to a theory with a set-theoretic ontology. Though Quine has recognized the possibility of an ideological debacle, his rebuttal is unconvincing. As a result, his tenet of extensionalism is under heavy pressure.
منابع مشابه
Prediction of debacle points for robustness of biological pathways by using recurrent neural networks.
Living organisms have ingenious control mechanisms in which many molecular interactions work for keeping their normal activities against disturbances inside and outside of them. However, at the same time, the control mechanism has debacle points at which the stability can be broken easily. This paper proposes a new method which uses recurrent neural network for predicting debacle points in an h...
متن کاملQuine on Indeterminacy
W.V. Quine’s thesis of the indeterminacy of translation is the theory which launched a thousand doctorates. During the 1970s it sometimes seemed to be as firmly entrenched a dogma among North American philosophers as the existence of God was among medieval theologians. Although now subject to much more by way of critical appraisal, Quine’s work is still, rightly, at the forefront of contemporar...
متن کاملTHE SAVINGS AND LOAN DEBACLE: A Perspective from the Early Twenty-First Century
The savings and loan debacle of the 1980s was a costly but important learning event for depository regulation in the United States. The origins of the debacle lay in restrictive government regulation that eventually led to financial difficulties for savings and loan institutions in the late 1970s and early 1980s. The Congress and at least three presidential administrations delayed for far too l...
متن کاملChapter 5: Revisability and Conceptual Change
Perhaps the most famous attack on Carnap’s logical empiricism is W.V. Quine’s article “Two Dogmas of Empiricism”. In the article, Quine argues against the analytic/synthetic distinction that Carnap employs, as well as against his sometime verificationism. The article is widely regarded as much more than an attack on logical empiricism, however. It is often seen as the most important critique of...
متن کاملReconstructing Quine: the Troubles with a Tradition*
There has developed in the professional literature a distinct tradition of interpreting and reconstructing Quine’s epistemology. The tradition has its roots in Gilbert Harman’s influential interpretation of Quine as an empiricist and in Harman’s reconstruction of Quine’s views on meaning.’ Richard Rorty, and those influenced by what may fairly be called the “Princeton School” of Quine scholarsh...
متن کامل