Vague Composition Without Vague Existence
نویسنده
چکیده
David Lewis (1986) criticizes moderate views of composition on the grounds that a restriction on composition must be vague, and vague composition leads, via a precisificational theory of vagueness, to an absurd vagueness of existence. I show how to resist this argument. Unlike the usual resistance, however, I do not jettison precisificational views of vagueness. Instead, I blur the connection between composition and existence that Lewis assumes. On the resulting view, in troublesome cases of vague composition, there is an object, which definitely exists, about which it is vague whether the relevant borderline parts compose it. I think that there are objects—my chair, for example—that are composed of several material objects. But I deny that there is anything composed of my nose and the Eiffel tower. So I’m a moderate about composition, since I think that there is a restriction on composition, but not a total restriction. Furthermore, I think that the restriction is more or less what you would intuitively take it to be: noses are in; towers are in; tower-noses are out. David Lewis (1986) claims that this view is committed to the possibility of an incoherent sort of vague existence, and he concludes that composition is in fact unrestricted.1 As he puts it: 1 Also see Ted Sider (2001, 120 – 32) for an elaboration and defense of the argument. Sider extends the argument to support four-dimensionalism as well as unrestricted composition. The argument has received a great deal of attention in the literature. For example, see van Inwagen (1990, section 19), Markosian (1998a; 2004), Hawley (2002), Koslicki (2003), Merricks (2005), Hawthorne (2006), Nolan (2006), and Smith (2006).
منابع مشابه
MINIMIZATION OF DETERMINISTIC FINITE AUTOMATA WITH VAGUE (FINAL) STATES AND INTUITIONISTIC FUZZY (FINAL) STATES
In this paper, relations among the membership values of gener- alized fuzzy languages such as intuitionistic fuzzy language, interval-valued fuzzy language and vague language are studied. It will aid in studying the properties of one language when the properties of another are known. Further, existence of a minimized nite automaton with vague ( final) states for any vague regular language recog...
متن کاملIDEALS OF PSEUDO MV-ALGEBRAS BASED ON VAGUE SET THEORY
The notion of vague ideals in pseudo MV-algebras is introduced,and several properties are investigated. Conditions for a vague set to be avague ideal are provided. Conditions for a vague ideal to be implicative aregiven. Characterizations of (implicative, prime) vague ideals are discussed.The smallest vague ideal containing a given vague set is established. Primeand implicative extension proper...
متن کاملThe Shapley value for fuzzy games on vague sets
In this paper, a general expression of the Shapley value for fuzzy games on vague sets is proposed, where the player participation levels are vague sets. The existence and uniqueness of the given Shapley value are showed by establishing axiomatic system. When the fuzzy games on vague sets are convex, the given Shapley value is a vague population monotonic allocation function (VPMAF) and an elem...
متن کاملA note on vague graphs
In this paper, we introduce the notions of product vague graph, balanced product vague graph, irregularity and total irregularity of any irregular vague graphs and some results are presented. Also, density and balanced irregular vague graphs are discussed and some of their properties are established. Finally we give an application of vague digraphs.
متن کامل