P&R 42-2_04.indd
نویسندگان
چکیده
Argument from analogy is a common and formidable form of reasoning in law and in everyday conversation. Although there is substantial literature on the subject, according to a recent survey ( Juthe 2005) there is little fundamental agreement on what form the argument should take, or on how it should be evaluated. Th e lack of conformity, no doubt, stems from the complexity and multiplicity of forms taken by arguments that fall under the umbrella of analogical reasoning in argumentation, dialectical studies, and law. Modeling arguments with argumentation schemes has proven useful in attempts to refi ne the analyst’s understanding of not only the logical structures that shape the backbone of the argument itself, but also the logical underpinning of strategies for evaluating it, strategies based on the semantic categories of genus and relevance. By clarifying the distinction between argument from example and argument from analogy, it is possible to advance a useful proposal for the treatment of argument from analogy in law.
منابع مشابه
On topological filtration for Severi-Brauer varieties II
The topological filtration on K ′ 0 of a Severi-Brauer variety is computed if the quotient of its index and exponent is a squarefree number and for each prime p dividing this quotient the p -primary component of the corresponding division algebra is decomposable. This gives in particular a description of Ch for such varieties. Let D be a central simple algebra over a field F and X = SB(D) the S...
متن کامل139-172 PPG_094081.indd
Understanding climate change and its potential impact on species, populations and communities is one of the most pressing questions of twenty-fi rst-century conservation planning. Palaeobiogeographers working on Cenozoic fossil records and other lines of evidence are producing important insights into the naturally dynamic nature of climate and the equally dynamic response of species, population...
متن کاملArticle 25.indd
This study investigated the possible antinociceptive effect of p-cymene in different tests of orofacial nociception. The animals (mice) were pretreated (i.p.) with p-cymene (25, 50, 100 mg/kg), morphine (5 mg/kg), or vehicle (0.2% Tween 80+saline), and were then subsequently administered, subcutaneously into their upper lip: formalin, capsaicin, and glutamate. The nociceptive behavior response ...
متن کاملSynthesis and Reactions of 3-Unsubstituted 2-Isoxazolines
Pohjakallio_176x250.indd 3 4.3.2011 10.34 Abstract_Pohjakallio_176x250.indd 3 4.3.2011 10.34Pohjakallio_176x250.indd 3 4.3.2011 10.34 2-Isoksatsoliinit ovat heterosyklisiä yhdisteitä, joita voidaan käyttää monipuolisesti synteettisinä välivaiheina erilaisten hyödyllisten rakenneyksiköiden valmistamisessa. 2-Isoksatsoliinien hyödyllisyys on pitkään perustunut niiden helppoon synteesiin erityises...
متن کامل