The effect of foregone payoffs on underweighting small probability events
نویسندگان
چکیده
Foregone payoffs add information about the outcomes for alternatives that are not chosen. The present paper examines the effect of foregone payoffs on underweighting rare but possible events in repeated choice tasks. Previous studies have not demonstrated any long-lasting effects of foregone payoffs (following repeated presentation of a task) when foregone payoffs do not add much information. The present paper highlights the conditions and the contributing factors for the occurrence of such long-lasting effects. An experimental study compares the effect of foregone payoffs under different degrees of rarity of the negative payoff. It is demonstrated that foregone payoffs increase the selection from risky alternatives with extremely rare and highly negative outcomes, and that this effect does not diminish with repeated presentation of the task. These findings can be summarized using a surprisingly simple reinforcement-learning model. The findings are discussed in the context of the potential long-term effect of social learning.
منابع مشابه
When and why rare events are underweighted: a direct comparison of the sampling, partial feedback, full feedback and description choice paradigms.
Two paradigms are commonly used to examine risky choice based on experiential sampling. The feedback paradigm involves a large number of repeated, consequential choices with feedback about the chosen (partial feedback) or chosen and foregone (full feedback) payoffs. The sampling paradigm invites cost-free samples before a single consequential choice. Despite procedural differences, choices in b...
متن کاملForegone with the Wind
In an attempt to improve our understanding of the effects of foregone payoffs on learning, the current paper examines the adaptation in decision tasks with a large number of choice alternatives. Our experimental setup varies the feedback about foregone payoffs. Study 1 shows that foregone payoffs can induce strong round–to–round sequential dependencies in the data. Study 2 demonstrates that inf...
متن کاملAre probabilities overweighted or underweighted when rare outcomes are experienced (rarely)?
When making decisions involving risky outcomes on the basis of verbal descriptions of the outcomes and their associated probabilities, people behave as if they overweight small probabilities. In contrast, when the same outcomes are instead experienced in a series of samples, people behave as if they underweight small probabilities. We present two experiments showing that the existing explanatio...
متن کاملPreliminary – DO NOT CIRCULATE Underweighting rare events in experience-based decisions: Beyond sample error
Recent research has focused on the difference between description and experience based decisions and on their treatment of rare events. While rare events are overweighted in description based decisions, people tend to behave as if they underweight rare events in decisions based on experience. Barron and Erev (2003) and Hertwig et al. (2004) argue that such findings are substantive and call for ...
متن کاملBiased samples not mode of presentation: Re-examining the apparent underweighting of rare events in experience-based choice
Most experimental investigations of risky choice provide participants with a description of the probabilities and outcomes for each option, and observe that small probabilities are overweighted. However, when payoffs are learned from repeated experience of outcomes (as in many real-world decisions), different patterns of choice are observed—consistent with underweighting rare events. We re-exam...
متن کامل