Against Many-Worlds Interpretations
نویسنده
چکیده
This is a critical review of the literature on many-worlds interpretations (MWI), with arguments drawn partly from earlier critiques by Bell and Stein. The essential postulates involved in various MWI are extracted, and their consistency with the evident physical world is examined. Arguments are presented against MWI proposed by Everett, Graham and DeWitt. The relevance of frequency operators to MWI is examined; it is argued that frequency operator theorems of Hartle and Farhi-Goldstone-Gutmann do not in themselves provide a probability interpretation for quantum mechanics, and thus neither support existing MWI nor would be useful in constructing new MWI. Comments are made on papers by Geroch and Deutsch that advocate MWI. It is concluded that no plausible set of axioms exists for an MWI that describes
منابع مشابه
Against \against Many-worlds Interpretations" Typeset Using Revt E X
The paper entitled \Against Many-Worlds Interpretations" by A. Kent, which has recently been submitted to the e-Print archive (gr-qc/9703089) contained some misconceptions. The claims on Everett's many-worlds interpretation are quoted and answered.
متن کاملThe many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics: psychological versus physical bases for the multiplicity of “worlds”
A crucial distinction in discussions of the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics (MWI) is that between versions of the interpretation positing a physical multiplicity of worlds, and those in which the multiplicity is merely psychological, and due to the splitting of consciousness upon interaction with amplified quantum superpositions. It is argued that Everett’s original version of t...
متن کاملOn Schizophrenic Experiences of the Neutron or Why We Should Believe in the Many-worlds Interpretation of Quantum Theory
There are many interpretations of quantum mechanics, and new ones continue to appear. The Many-Worlds Interpretation (MWI) introduced by Everett (1957) impresses me as the best candidate for the interpretation of quantum theory. My belief is not based on a philosophical affinity for the idea of plurality of worlds as in Lewis (1986), but on a judgment that the physical difficulties of other int...
متن کاملProbability and Nonlocality in Many Minds Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics
We argue that a certain type of many minds (and many worlds) interpretations of quantum mechanics due to Lockwood (and Deutsch) do not provide a coherent interpretation of the quantum mechanical probabilistic algorithm. By contrast, in Albert and Loewer’s version of the many minds interpretation there is a coherent interpretation of the quantum mechanical probabilities. We consider Albert and L...
متن کاملQuantum probability and many worlds
We discuss the meaning of probabilities in the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics. We start by presenting very briefly the many worlds theory, how the problem of probability arises, and some unsuccessful attempts to solve it in the past. Then we criticize a recent attempt by Deutsch to derive the quantum mechanical probabilities from the non-probabilistic parts of quantum mechanics...
متن کامل