Contemplative, interventionist, constructionist and creationist idea(l)s in (techno)science
نویسندگان
چکیده
Within the realm of nano-, bio-, infoand cogno(or NBIC) technosciences, the ‘power to change the world’ is often invoked. One could dismiss such formulations as ‘purely rhetorical’, interpret them as rhetorical and self-fulfilling or view them as an adequate depiction of one of the fundamental characteristics of technoscience. In the latter case, a very specific nexus between science and technology, or, the epistemic and the constructionist realm is envisioned. The following paper focuses on this nexus drawing on theoretical conceptions as well as empirical material. It presents an overview of different technoscientific ways to ‘change the world’—via contemplation and representation, intervention and control, engineering, construction and creation. It further argues that the hybrid character of technoscience makes it difficult (if not impossible) to separate knowledge production from real world interventions and challenges current science and technology policy approaches in fundamental ways. Résumé Dans le monde des nano-, bio-, infoet cogno(ou NBIC) technosciences, le «pouvoir de changer le monde» est souvent invoqué. Ces formulations pourraient être mises de côté comme «purement rhétoriques», ou bien interprétées comme étant rhétoriques et auto-réalisatrices, ou bien vues comme une description adéquate d’une des caractéristiques fondamentales de la technoscience. Dans le dernier cas, une connexion bien spécifique est imaginée entre la science et la technologie, ou bien le monde épistémique et obstructionniste. Cet article se K. Kastenhofer (&) Institute of Technology Assessment, Austrian Academy of Sciences, Strohgasse 45/5, 1030 Wien, Austria e-mail: [email protected] J. C. Schmidt Unit of Social, Culture and Technology Studies, Darmstadt University of Applied Sciences, Haardtring 100, 64295 Darmstadt, Germany e-mail: [email protected] 123 Poiesis Prax (2011) 8:125–149 DOI 10.1007/s10202-011-0101-2
منابع مشابه
Synthetic biology as understanding, control, construction, and creation? Techno-epistemic and socio-political implications of different stances in talking and doing technoscience
Systems biology and synthetic biology are said to represent ‘two sides of the same coin,’ with systems biology focussing on understanding and synthetic biology on construction. This notion is based on the implicit assumption that understanding and construction (or science and engineering) are, in themselves, ‘two sides of the same coin.’ Moreover, synthetic biology has been framed as an approac...
متن کاملTeaching Contemplative Listening in an Age of Sonic Overload
Music certainly has a long tradition of being used as an aid to contemplative modes of thinking, but the kind of music usually associated with college youth—popular music forms currently in vogue—are primarily focused on the kinesthetic and sexual nature of youth. Young people have a high energy level which is often expressed in dancing and other activities requiring music “with a beat.” In add...
متن کاملDefining Contemplative Science: The Metacognitive Self-Regulatory Capacity of the Mind, Context of Meditation Practice and Modes of Existential Awareness
The term 'contemplative' is now frequently used in the fast growing field of meditation research. Yet, there is no consensus regarding the definition of contemplative science. Meditation studies commonly imply that contemplative practices such as mindfulness or compassion are the subject of contemplative science. Such approach, arguably, contributes to terminological confusions in the field, is...
متن کاملContemplative Science and Secular Ethics
This article argues that the emerging project of contemplative science will be best served if it is informed by two perspectives. First, attention should be paid not only to non-analytical and/or mindfulness-based practices, but to a fuller range of contemplative practices, including analytical styles of meditation. Second, the issue of ethics must be addressed as a framework within which to un...
متن کاملAn Interventionist Approach to Causation in Psychology
My project in this paper is to extend the interventionist analysis of causation to give an account of causation in psychology. Many aspects of empirical investigation into psychological causation fit straightforwardly into the interventionist framework. I address three problems. First, the problem of explaining what it is for a causal relation to be properly psychological rather than merely bio...
متن کامل