Utterances and Their Meanings
ثبت نشده
چکیده
Meanings are constructed situationally by the participants in interaction, as they construe intent in each other’s uttered words. A well-known story (said to be a favorite of both Vygotsky and Bakhtin) tells of a group of sailors having a nuanced exchange by repeating the same expletive to each other, but with a different intonation and timing at each turn. This polysemousness of words is equally to be found in an office memo announcing a change in reporting procedures that leaves the recipients wondering what the real meaning is—from enacting a corporate shake-up, to disciplining a co-worker, to a power-grab by a manager, to simply creating an efficiency. Much water-cooler time may be devoted to examining the nuances of expression or sharing other contexting information until a stable social meaning is agreed on, which will then guide the behavior of all concerned. To put it explicitly, meaning is not a property of language in itself, and is not immanent in language. Meaning is what people construe using the prosthesis of language, interpreted within specific contexts of use. To understand meaning, we need to take utterance and people’s construal of utterance as our fundamental units of analysis.
منابع مشابه
Experiments Using OSTIA for a Language Production Task
The phenomenon of meaning-preserving corrections given by an adult to a child involves several aspects: (1) the child produces an incorrect utterance, which the adult nevertheless understands, (2) the adult produces a correct utterance with the same meaning and (3) the child recognizes the adult utterance as having the same meaning as its previous utterance, and takes that as a signal that its ...
متن کاملA Probabilistic Model of Syntactic and Semantic Acquisition from Child-Directed Utterances and their Meanings
This paper presents an incremental probabilistic learner that models the acquistion of syntax and semantics from a corpus of child-directed utterances paired with possible representations of their meanings. These meaning representations approximate the contextual input available to the child; they do not specify the meanings of individual words or syntactic derivations. The learner then has to ...
متن کاملSome More Thoughts About Thought and Talk:
1. One tenet of Donald Davidson's account of radical interpretation is the interdependence of utterance interpretation and belief ascription. Assigning meanings to a speaker's utterances requires interpreters to make concomitant determinations of their beliefs. But at the same time, one cannot fix the contents of a subject's beliefs without identifying the meanings of their utterances. So belie...
متن کاملContext and Implicitness: Consequences for Qualitative and Quantitative Context Analysis
In the framework of discourse analysis the relationship between explicit and implicit meaning is discussed. The discussion is based on verbal discriminations in private and public discourses. Implicit meanings of sentences cannot be inferred directly from their content or from the meanings of individual words within an utterance. Rather, they can be understood from the context in which the utte...
متن کاملSemantic Generalisation and the Inference of Meaning
In this paper, a computational model of a successful negotiated communication system is presented, in which language agents develop their own meanings in response to their environment and attempt to infer the meanings of others’ utterances. The inherent uncertainty in the process of meaning inference in the system leads to variation in the agents’ internal semantic representations, which then i...
متن کاملGrounding Word Meanings In Sensor Data: Dealing With Referential Uncertainty
We consider the problem of how the meanings of words can be grounded in sensor data. A probabilistic representation for the meanings of words is defined, a method for recovering meanings from observational information about word use in the face of referential uncertainty is described, and empirical results with real utterances and robot sensor data are presented.
متن کامل