The Cost of Biased Insurer Ratings
نویسندگان
چکیده
Numerous firms offer competing ratings of insurer financial condition. Insurance consumers, producers, and others commonly puzzle over which rating is more accurate. A 1994 Government Accounting Office (GAO) report judged the performance of a group of these insurance rating agencies. That report focused on Type I error (i.e., too high a rating on an insurer that defaults) rather than an appropriate balance between Type I and Type II error (i.e., too low a rating on an insurer that is financially stronger than indicated by the rating). This study investigates the consequences of focusing on Type I errors. We assume that both the demand and supply of insurance are related to an insurer’s rating. Using these assumptions, a model demonstrates the theoretical existence of a set of optimal insurer ratings and the societal cost imposed by rating-induced deviations from this set.
منابع مشابه
Life Insurer Financial Distress, Best's Ratings and Financial Ratios
This study compares the predictive ability of: (1) ratings, rating changes and total assets; (2) financial ratios; and (3) financial ratios combined with ratings and rating changes on a sample of forty-eight insolvent life insurers over the period 1990 to 1992. Based on the expected cost of misclassification, ratings, rating changes and total assets have comparable predictive ability to financi...
متن کاملProperty-liability Insurer Financial Strength Ratings: Differences across Rating Agencies
Regulators, investors, consumers, and insurance brokers use insurer financial strength ratings to evaluate the insolvency risk of insurers. This article investigates the factors influencing the decision to obtain a rating or multiple ratings, the determinants of ratings for the three major insurer rating agencies, and reasons for differences in ratings across agencies. This study indicates that...
متن کاملThe Effects of China's Growth in Manufacturing Sector in the U.S. Economy
T his paper investigates the gain of bilateral trade between China and U.S. in manufacturing sectors when both countries play a role in asymmetric (biased) growth of international trade. Our model includes a special case of Biased Growth Theory in international trade. We collected labor productivity, export and import data by using classification of manufacturing industries, for U.S...
متن کاملGeneralization of Decomposed Integration Methods for Cost Effective Heat Exchanger Networks with Multiple Cost Laws
At many circumstances, in heat exchange processes several exchangers were used with different cost laws due to their pressure ratings, materials of construction and exchange3r types. In such circumstances traditional methods of pinch technology can not be led to minimum total annual cost may cause some other disadvantages like more complexity or higher maintenance. In this research work a n...
متن کاملComputational modeling of 1994 A.M. Best life/health insurer ratings
The insurance industry is the major intermediator of long term credit in the U.S., and insurance ratings agencies have become powerful de facto regulators of insurance company investment policy and hence of capital allocation for the economy as a whole. If the rating process can be shown to be dishonest, arbitrary, or even simply lacking in rigor, the implications for the proper role of insuran...
متن کامل