Final version Spatial Perception via Tactile Sensation

If a sensory brain state plays an unusual functional role, does the phenomenology go with the role or the brain state? If the phenomenology goes with the functional role, that supports functionalism, which is the view that phenomenology just is the role. If it goes with the brain state, that supports physicalism, which is the view that phenomenology is what realizes or implements the role. I agree with Gray [1] as against Noë and Hurley [3] that the interest of the issues discussed by Hurley and Noë [2] lies in their relevance to the functionalism/physicalism debate. However, I do not think that Hurley and Noë have made it plausible that there are any cases in which phenomenology goes with role when role and realizer conflict.