Surnames and a Theory of Social Mobility
نویسنده
چکیده
Using the information content of surnames to measure social mobility, it is shown that the true intergenerational correlation of social status is in the order of 0.7-0.8, much higher than is estimated by conventional methods. This intergenerational correlation is similar across dramatically different societies: medieval England, modern England, pre-industrial Sweden, modern Sweden, the USA, Quing and Communist China, Meiji and modern Japan, and Chile. Surnames also show mobility to follow a simple law-like process across many generations. One simple Law of Motion seems to capture all social mobility. In this paper I offer a theory as to why these measures differ from conventional mobility estimates. I also argue that the nature of the process suggests biological inheritance of abilities, as opposed to intergenerational capital transfers, is the main determinant of social position.
منابع مشابه
What is the True Rate of Social Mobility? Evidence from the Information Content of Surnames
What is the true rate of social mobility? Modern one-generation studies of individual families suggest considerable regression to the mean for all measures of status – wealth, income, occupation, and education-across a variety of societies. The b that links status across generations is in the order of 0.2-0.5. In that case inherited surnames will quickly lose any information about social status...
متن کاملSurnames and the Laws of Social Mobility
What is the true rate of social mobility? Modern one-generation studies suggest considerable regression to the mean for all measures of status – wealth, income, occupation and education across a variety of societies. The β that links status across generations is in the order of 0.2-0.5. In that case inherited surnames will quickly lose any information about social status. Using surnames this pa...
متن کاملWhat is the True Rate of Social Mobility ? Surnames and Social Mobility , England , 1800 - 2012
Using rare surnames we follow the socio-economic status of initial groups of rich, middling, and poor in England from 1800 until 2012. We measure social status through wealth, education, occupation, membership in political elites, and average age at death. Our method allows unbiased estimates of mobility rates. Mobility rates are much lower than conventionally estimated, including the most rece...
متن کاملSurnames and Social Status in Spain
We study the information contained in surnames on the socioeconomic status of people in Spain. We find that people bearing uncommon surnames tend to enjoy a higher socioeconomic status than people bearing more common surnames. This bias is statistically very significant and robust to di erent measures of socioeconomic status, and it holds at the national aggregate level as well as at the region...
متن کاملIntergenerational Wealth Mobility in England, 1858-2012. Surnames and Social Mobility
This paper uses a panel of 21,618 people with rare surnames whose wealth is observed at death in England and Wales 1858-2012 to measure the intergenerational elasticity of wealth over five generations. We show, using rare surnames to track families, that wealth is much more persistent than standard one generation estimates would suggest. There is still a significant correlation between the weal...
متن کامل