Between Laws and Models: Some Philosophical Morals of Lagrangian Mechanics

I extract some philosophical morals from some aspects of Lagrangian mechanics. (A companion paper will present similar morals from Hamiltonian mechanics and Hamilton-Jacobi theory.) One main moral concerns methodology: Lagrangian mechanics provides a level of description of phenomena which has been largely ignored by philosophers, since it falls between their accustomed levels—“laws of nature” and “models”. Another main moral concerns ontology: the ontology of Lagrangian mechanics is both more subtle and more problematic than philosophers often realize. The treatment of Lagrangian mechanics provides an introduction to the subject for philosophers, and is technically elementary. In particular, it is confined to systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom, and for the most part eschews modern geometry. Newton’s fundamental discovery, the one which he considered necessary to keep secret and published only in the form of an anagram, consists of the following: Data aequatione quotcunque fluentes quantitae involvente fluxiones invenire et vice versa. In contemporary mathematical language, this means: “It is useful to solve differential equations”. V. Arnold, Geometrical Methods in the Theory of Ordinary Differential Equations, Preface email: [email protected]; [email protected]