Laws are conditionals
نویسنده
چکیده
The ubiquitous schema ‘All Fs are Gs’ dominates much philosophical discussion on laws but rarely is it shown how actual laws mentioned and used in science are supposed to fit it. After consideration of a variety of laws, including those obviously conditional and those superficially not conditional (such as equations), I argue that we have good reason to support the traditional interpretation of laws as conditionals of some quantified form with a single object variable. I show how this conclusion impacts on the status of ‘system laws’ and the significance of having only one object variable with regard to the relationship between laws and causal relations.
منابع مشابه
Noa Latham Davidson and Kim on Psychophysical Laws
Nearly 30 years have passed since Donald Davidson first presented his argument against the possibility of psychophysical laws in “Mental Events”. The argument applies to intentional rather than phenomenal properties, so whenever I refer to mental properties and to psychophysical laws it should be understood that I mean intentional properties and laws relating them to physical properties. No con...
متن کاملA Note on Scientific Essentialism, Laws of Nature, and Counterfactual Conditionals
Scientific essentialism aims to account for the natural laws’ special capacity to support counterfactuals. I argue that scientific essentialism can do so only by resorting to devices that are just as ad hoc as those that essentialists accuse Humean regularity theories of employing. I conclude by offering an account of the laws’ distinctive relation to counterfactuals that portrays laws as conti...
متن کاملCausality and counterfactual conditionals
This paper deals with the truth conditions of conditional sentences. It focuses on a particular class of problematic examples for semantic theories for these sentences. I will argue that the examples show the need to refer to dynamic, in particular causal laws in an approach to their truth conditions. More particularly, I will claim that we need a causal notion of consequence. The proposal subs...
متن کاملConditionals from a linguistic point of view: Two case studies
The meaning of conditional sentences bears an intrinsic relation to a number of central philosophical problems, like the nature of reasoning, the possibility of knowledge, and the status of laws of nature. This has incited philosophers to spend a lot of time working on conditionals and to fill countless bookshelves with inspiring and sophisticated theories on their meaning. However, the overall...
متن کاملCompatibility results for conditional distributions
In various frameworks, to assess the joint distribution of a kdimensional random vector X = (X1, . . . , Xk), one selects some putative conditional distributions Q1, . . . , Qk. Each Qi is regarded as a possible (or putative) conditional distribution for Xi given (X1, . . . , Xi−1, Xi+1, . . . , Xk). The Qi are compatible if there is a joint distribution P for X with conditionals Q1, . . . , Qk...
متن کامل