Should Bayesians Bet Where Frequentists Fear to Tread?*
نویسنده
چکیده
Probability theory is important not least because of its relevance for decision making, which also means: its relevance for the single case. The frequency theory of probability on its own is irrelevant in the single case. However, Howson and Urbach argue that Bayesianism can solve the frequentist’s problem: frequentist-probability information is relevant to Bayesians (although to nobody else). The present paper shows that Howson and Urbach’s solution cannot work, and indeed that no Bayesian solution can work. There is no way to make frequentist probability relevant.
منابع مشابه
Bayesianism, frequentism, and the planted clique, or do algorithms believe in unicorns?
Both sides agree that it is correct, but they disagree on what the symbols mean. For frequentists, probabilities refer to the fraction that an event happens over repeated samples. They think of probability as counting, or an extension of combinatorics. For Bayesians, probabilities refer to degrees of belief, or, if you want, the odds that you would place on a bet. They see probability as an ext...
متن کاملBeyond Bayesians and Frequentists
If you are a newly initiated student into the field of machine learning, it won’t be long before you start hearing the words “Bayesian” and “frequentist” thrown around. Many people around you probably have strong opinions on which is the “right” way to do statistics, and within a year you’ve probably developed your own strong opinions (which are suspiciously similar to those of the people aroun...
متن کاملWhy Frequentists and Bayesians Need Each Other
The orthodox view in statistics has it that frequentism and Bayesianism are diametrically opposed—two totally incompatible takes on the problem of statistical inference. This paper argues to the contrary that the two approaches are complementary and need to mesh if probabilistic reasoning is to be carried out correctly.
متن کاملBayesians, Frequentists, and Physicists
PHYSTAT2003 brought statisticians together with particle physicists, astrophysicists, and cosmologists. This paper, which is taken from the text of the keynote address, concerns the uneasy relationship between Bayesian and frequentist statistics, with particular attention to the “neutrino problem”: how to set confidence limits for a parameter known to be non-negative. Model selection, an object...
متن کامل