How to Make the Team: Social Networks vs. Demography as Criteria for Designing Effective Teams
نویسندگان
چکیده
We compare two alternative approaches for evaluating the potential of a work group or team: one that focuses on team members’ demographic characteristics and one that focuses on the members’ social networks. Given that people’s network contacts often share their demographic attributes (i.e., the network is homophilous), the two approaches seem equivalent, and the first seems preferable because it is easier to implement. In this paper, we demonstrate several important limits to this rationale. First, we argue and show, in an analysis of 1,518 project teams in a contract research and development firm, that even when internal organizational networks are significantly homophilous with respect to demographic variables, the very logic of the causal structure that underlies theories of demographic diversity carries ambiguous performance implications. This ambiguity is due to the fact that demographic diversity has opposing effects on two social network variables—internal density and external range—that each has a positive effect on a teams’ performance. We also demonstrate that a focus on demographic criteria is problematic because the demographic makeup of an organization can place inherent limits on a manager’s ability to shape the demographic composition of a team. The ambiguous performance implications and the inherent limits placed on a manager’s ability to manage a teams’ demography reduce the likelihood that a manger’s interventions will be successful. The performance implications of managing a team’s social capital, however, are clear.
منابع مشابه
An improved particle swarm optimization with a new swap operator for team formation problem
Formation of effective teams of experts has played a crucial role in successful projects especially in social networks. In this paper, a new particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm is proposed for solving a team formation optimization problem by minimizing the communication cost among experts. The proposed algorithm is called by improved particle optimization with new swap operator (IPSONSO...
متن کاملAn Analytic Model for Organization Readiness of Engineering Project Management Based on Virtual Teams
The Organization Readiness of Engineering Project Management Based on Virtual Teams has been analyzed in an Iranian Engineering firm. Adapting and analyzing the latest readiness model, experts’ opinions were received by questionnaires and main criteria of the readiness have been identified. The considered readiness criteria are: Infrastructure, Deliverables (Drawings, Reports, Minutes of Meeti...
متن کاملBuilding Successful Software Development Teams Using TSP and Effective Communication Networks
Social network models can help explain how and why some organizational structures and practices work. Moreover, network analysis is accessible to engineering practitioners and is particularly effective in helping us understand the value of Team Software Process (TSP). Networks not only offer an explanation of how TSP works with respect to communication, but also suggest that as we scale beyond ...
متن کاملOrganization and Preparedness of Emergency and Disaster Medical Response Teams: Obstacles and Challenges
Background: Rising trend of emergencies and disasters in the world has caused a lot of damage to the health care facility infrastructures. This has led the health needs of the affected population to be the first and most requirement in emergencies and disasters. In most countries for the timely and appropriate response to the health needs of the affected areas, structured and organized teams ar...
متن کاملInformation sharing systems and teamwork between sub-teams: a mathematical modeling perspective
Teamwork contributes to a considerable improvement in quality and quantity of the ultimate outcome. Collaboration and alliance between team members bring a substantial progress for any business. However, it is imperative to acquire an appropriate team since many factors must be considered in this regard. Team size may represent the effectiveness of a team and it is of paramount importance to de...
متن کامل