Sequential Procurement Auctions
نویسندگان
چکیده
Procurement by governments accounts for 10-15 percent of national product in most Western nations [McAfee and McMillan (1985a)]. Consequently, analyses of procurement policies apply to a significant portion of economic activity. This paper considers sequential procurement: a buyer will purchase items in sequence, with costs correlated across time. Thus, if auctions are held, bids in the first auction reveal something about costs in the second. This paper, then, contributes to the optimal auction literature, with the major application in government procurement. It is arguable that nonsequential procurement is the exception; once a government buys an item, it continues buying it for the rest of time. Governments fix roads, buy military items, plant trees, etc. every year. These all represent sequentially procured items. Often the same firms bid each year, and this is presumed here for simplicity. Research and development projects are often followed by production projects. Generally, the winner of the R&D project (the incumbent) has an advantage in production, for he may have learned something useful during the research that he keeps secret, or because the mere fact that he won the R&D bidding is itself a signal of an advantage in this area. Such a situation means that the government possesses useful information: in the second project, expectations concerning the incumbent do not coincide with expect-
منابع مشابه
Performance and Analysis of Spot Truck-load Procurement Markets Using Sequential Auctions
Title of Dissertation / Thesis: PERFORMANCE AND ANALYSIS OF SPOT TRUCK-LOAD PROCUREMENT MARKETS USING SEQUENTIAL AUCTIONS Miguel Andres Figliozzi, Ph.D., 2004 Dissertation / Thesis Directed By: Professor Hani Mahmassani, Civil and Environmental Engineering Department Competition in a transportation marketplace is studied under different supply/demand conditions, auction formats, and carriers’ b...
متن کاملOn the Drawbacks of Sequential Auctions for Multiple Objects with Aysmmetric Bidder
Sequential first price auctions of multiple lots are very common in procurement, electricity, tobacco, timber, and oil lease. Presumably, they are common because they are easier to organize to than simultaneous ones. In this paper we identify two ways in which a sequential format may facilitate collusion among bidders relative to a simultaneous one, and we analyze the seller’s disclosure polici...
متن کاملConcession-making in Multi-bilateral Negotiations and Multi-attribute Auctions
Reverse auctions and negotiations are two common procurement mechanisms. The drawback of many auctions is their sole focus on price. The drawback of negotiations is that they are sequential, slow and costly. Internet enables multi-attribute auctions and multi-bilateral multi-attribute negotiations efficiently. In both processes concession-making plays a key role. The paper presents typology of ...
متن کاملOptimal Bidding in Sequential Procurement Auctions
We consider the problem of a firm that in each period procures items by participating in auctions and then it sells the acquired items by the end of the period, where any unsold items are salvaged. The objective of the firm is to have a bidding policy that maximizes the expected value of its profit over N auctions. In this model the firm’s valuations derive from the resale of acquired items via...
متن کاملEntry decisions and bidding behavior in sequential first-price procurement auctions: An experimental study
Though many real life auctions are run independently of each other, from the bidders’ point of view they often form sequences of auctions. We investigate how behavior responds to the additional incentives that are present in such auction sequences. Comparing subjects’ decisions in single first-price procurement auctions with their decisions in a game consisting of two subsequent first-price pro...
متن کامل