Capturing mental state reasoning with influence diagrams
نویسندگان
چکیده
People have a keen ability to reason about others’ mental states, which is central for communication and cooperation. A core question for cognitive science is what mental representations support this ability. We offer one proposal based on the framework of influence diagrams, an extension of Bayes nets that is suited for representing intentional goal-directed agents. We evaluate this framework in two experiments that require participants to make inferences about what another person knows or values. In both experiments, participants’ judgments were better predicted by our influence diagrams account than by several alternative accounts.
منابع مشابه
A Computational Account of Social Reasoning
People are amateur social psychologists: they explain other people’s behavior, infer what other people are thinking and feeling, and predict how other people will act. I will refer to this sort of psychologizing as social reasoning in order to highlight the fact that it involves reasoning about people. Social reasoning often requires significant leaps of inductive inference: people infer others...
متن کاملNetworks of Influence Diagrams: A Formalism for Reasoning about Agents’ Decision-making Processes
Traditional game-theoretic analysis for decision-making takes a normative approach, in which agents derive rational decisions from the game description. This approach cannot naturally and compactly capture agents that are uncertain about the structure of the game, the strategies of other agents or whether agents may deviate from their optimal strategy. This paper presents Networks of Influence ...
متن کاملDiagrammatic Reasoning by Simulation
Humans employ diagrams and other pictures, both real and imagined, as aids to reasoning, and many kinds of problems are solved by an interaction between perception-like processing and verbal reasoning. My research is exploring computational explanations of this interaction. The use of diagrams is in part a form of spatial reasoning, which is the use of representations of objects in space for pr...
متن کاملOn the Cognitive Efficacy of Euler Diagrams in Syllogistic Reasoning: A Relational Perspective
Although logic diagrams are widely used as methods for introducing students to elementary logical reasoning, it is still open to debate in cognitive psychology whether diagrams can aid untrained people to successfully conduct deductive reasoning. In our previous work, some empirical evidence was provided for the effectiveness of a certain type of logic diagrams in the process of solving categor...
متن کاملNetwork of Inlfuence Diagrams Networks of Influence Diagrams: A Formalism for Representing Agents’ Beliefs and Decision-Making Processes
This paper presents Networks of Influence Diagrams (NID), a compact, natural and highly expressive language for reasoning about agents’ beliefs and decision-making processes. NIDs are graphical structures in which agents’ mental models are represented as nodes in a network; a mental model for an agent may itself use descriptions of the mental models of other agents. NIDs are demonstrated by exa...
متن کامل