Can the TAG derivation tree represent a semantic graph? An answer in the light of Meaning-Text Theory
نویسندگان
چکیده
From the parsing point of view, the derivation tree in TAG [hereafter DT] is seen as the "history" of the derivation but also as a linguistic representation, closer to semantics, that can be the basis of a further analysis. Because in TAG the elementary trees are lexicalized and localize the predicate-arguments relations, several works have compared the DT to a structure involving dependencies between lexical items (RJ92; RVW95). We agree with these authors that there are divergences between the DT and syntactic dependencies, but we show here that the DT — in the sense of (SS94) — can be viewed as a semantic dependency graph, namely a SemS for Meaning-Text Theory [MTT] (ZM67; M88). This requires the predicate-argument cooccurrence principle and also constraints on the adjunction of predicative auxiliary trees. We briefly introduce the representation levels in MTT before studying the dependencies shown by the DT.
منابع مشابه
Defining DTG derivations to get semantic graphs
Tue aim of this paper is to find a fonnalism of the TAG family, where the derivation controller can be interpreted as a semantic dependency graph, in the sense of Meaning-Text Theory (ZM67; M88). In a previous paper (CK98), we study tliis interpretation of the derivation tree (DT) in the case of standard TAG. We prove that, in the general case, if the predieate-argument cooccurence principle1 [...
متن کاملA syntactic-semantic analysis of \"منصوب به نزع خافض\"based on the Holy Quran
One of important issues in the field of implication and aggression is "منصوب به نزع خافض". It is an idiom related to مفعول به "”. By referring to its definition, a syntactic-semantic analysis will be done in this paper. It tries to indicate what is the relationship between word and meaning and to what extent Arabic syntax focu...
متن کاملAn alternative description of extractions in TAG
The aim of the paper is to propose a new description of extraction in plain TAG. Contrary to Kroch 1987’s analysis, our description is based on the fact that the power of a relative clause to adjoin on a noun can be attached to the wh-word rather than to a verb. This analysis solves some problems of the previous analysis, notably by giving the right semantic dependency in case of pied-piping. W...
متن کاملDelayed Tree Locality and the Status of Derivation Structure
While the derived trees yielded by TAG derivations are uncontroversially taken to correspond to phrase structure, the status of TAG derivation structures as more than a record of TAG operations is less certain. An attractive possibility is to interpret the derivation structure as some representation of semantic meaning, such as a dependency analysis. However, the literature has identified cases...
متن کاملThe study of Cypress appearance in the Persian art and architecture in the light of Gestalt theory
The impetus behind this study is to discover the aesthetic and semantic patterns of the cypress tree and show how this element has been employed by Iranian artists. The question of this research is how a constant element (the cypress tree) has been transfigured in different Iranian arts. Four categories of miniature, carpet, textile and architecture decoration. The present research is qual...
متن کامل