Noncancer Risk Assessment: A Probabilistic Alternative to Current Practice
نویسندگان
چکیده
Based on imperfect data and theory, agencies such as the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) currently derive "reference doses" (RfDs) to guide risk managers charged with ensuring that human exposures to chemicals are below population thresholds. The RfD for a chemical is typically reported as a single number, even though it is widely acknowledged that there are significant uncertainties inherent in the derivation of this number. In this article, the authors propose a probabilistic alternative to the EPA's method that expresses the human population threshold as a probability distribution of values (rather than a single RfD value), taking into account the major sources of scientific uncertainty in such estimates. The approach is illustrated using much of the same data that USEPA uses to justify their current RfD procedure. Like the EPA's approach, our approach recognizes the four key extrapolations that are necessary to define the human population threshold based on animal data: animal to human, human heterogeneity, LOAEL to NOAEL, and subchronic to chronic. Rather than using available data to define point estimates of "uncertainty factors" for these extrapolations, the proposed approach uses available data to define a probability distribution of adjustment factors. These initial characterizations of uncertainty can then be refined when more robust or specific data become available for a particular chemical or class of chemicals. Quantitative characterization of uncertainty in noncancer risk assessment will be useful to risk managers who face complex trade-offs between control costs and protection of public health. The new approach can help decision-makers understand " Program in Environmental Health and Public Policy, Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, 665 Hunringtnn Ave., Boston, MA 02115; Tel: (617) 432-1259; Fax (617) 432-1226 ** Harvard Center for Risk Analysis, 718 Hunnngton Ave., Boston, MA 02115 *** Author to whom correspondence should be addressed. how much extra control cost must be expended to achieve a specified increase in confidence that the human population threshold is not being exceeded.
منابع مشابه
Risk characterization framework for noncancer end points.
The nature of both indoor air exposures and noncancer end points present significant issues for risk characterization. Noncancer end points are multidimensional, affecting various organs, and are assumed to have thresholds. Symptoms also vary in severity within a population. In addition to the complexity of noncancer risk assessment, indoor air exposures are typified by the presence of complex ...
متن کاملErratum: Incorrect Title of the Author. Opioid Pharmacotherapy for Chronic Noncancer Pain: The American Experience
Chronic noncancer pain is a significant and growing public health challenge in the United States. Lacking effective alternative interventions for effective chronic noncancer pain management, many physicians have turned to opioid pharmacotherapy. Increased opioid prescribing brings not only gains in therapeutic benefit but also a higher incidence of adverse drug events including increased medica...
متن کاملApplicable risk assessment methods in occupational and environmental exposure to nanoparticles - a narrative review
Nanoparticles (NPs) are a heterogeneous group of materials that have various applications, and their risk assessment is an essential condition. This study aimed to review the applicable risk assessment methods in occupational and environmental exposures to NPs. A literature search for articles published since 2005 in Web of Knowledge, Scopus, PubMed, Science Direct, and Google Scholar, using ap...
متن کاملExposure Assessment of Total Mercury: A Probabilistic-Approach Study Based on Consumption of Canned Fish
Introduction: Exposure to mercury (Hg) by consumption of fish is a recent health concern. So, it is important to evaluate the health risks related to canned fish consumption. The purpose of this study was to investigate the potential health risk based on Hg concentration in people who consumed canned fish with a probabilistic approach in Isfahan City, the central province in Iran. Materials an...
متن کاملDynamic Assessment in Iranian EFL Classrooms: A Post- method Enquiry
Derived from the emerging paradigm shift in English language teaching and assessment, there has been a renewal of interest in dynamic assessment (DA) to be used as an alternative to the traditional static testing in language classrooms. However, to date, DA practice has been mostly limited to clinical treatments of children with learning disabilities, and it has not been widely incorporated int...
متن کامل