Probabilistic power indices for games with abstention∗
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this paper we introduce eight power indices that admit a probabilistic interpretation for voting rules with abstention or with three levels of approval in the input, briefly (3,2) games. We analyze the analogies and discrepancies between standard known indices for simple games and the proposed extensions for this more general context. A remarkable difference is that for (3,2) games the proposed extensions of the Banzhaf index, Coleman index to prevent action and Coleman index to initiate action become non–proportional notions, contrarily to what succeeds for simple games. We conclude the work by providing procedures based on generating functions for (3,2) games, and extensible to (j,k) games, to efficiently compute them.
منابع مشابه
A Special Case of Penrose’s Limit Theorem When Abstention Is Allowed
In general, analyses of voting power are performed through the notion of a simple voting game (SVG) in which every voter can choose between two options: ‘yes’ or ‘no’. Felsenthal and Machover [Felsenthal, D.S. and Machover, M. (1997), International Journal of Game Theory 26, 335–351.] introduced the concept of ternary voting games (TVGs) which recognizes abstention alongside. They derive approp...
متن کاملAchievable hierarchies in voting games with abstention
It is well known that he inuence relation orders the voters the same way as the classical Banzhaf and Shapley-Shubik indices do when they are extended to the voting games with abstention (VGA) in the class of complete games. Moreover, all hierarchies for the inuence relation are achievable in the class of complete VGA. The aim of this paper is twofold. Firstly, we show that all hierarchies ar...
متن کاملPower in voting rules with abstention: an axiomatization of a two components power index
In order to study voting situations when voters can also abstain and the output can be only binary, i.e., either approval or rejection, a new extended model of voting rule was defined. Accordingly, indices of power, in particular Banzhaf's index, were considered. In this paper we argue that in this context a power index should be a pair of real numbers, since this better highlights the power of...
متن کاملThe Banzhaf power index on convex geometries
In this paper, we introduce the Banzhaf power indices for simple games on convex geometries. We define the concept of swing for these structures, obtaining convex swings. The number of convex swings and the number of coalitions such that a player is an extreme point are the basic tools to define the convex Banzhaf indices, one normalized and other probabilistic. We obtain a family of axioms tha...
متن کاملAxiomatic characterizations of probabilistic and cardinal-probabilistic interaction indices
In the framework of cooperative game theory, the concept of interaction index, which can be regarded as an extension of that of value, has been recently proposed to measure the interaction phenomena among players. Axiomatizations of two classes of interaction indices, namely probabilistic interaction indices and cardinal-probabilistic interaction indices, generalizing probabilistic values and s...
متن کامل