Laws and Makeups in Context-Dependent Reduction Relations
نویسنده
چکیده
One of the problems encountered in Philosophy of Mind is that cognitive theories have a nontrivial dependence on the context of specific neurological makeups or mechanisms of individuals and species. Due to this context-dependency, for example, regularities or relationships between cognitive states are not considered genuine laws and cannot be directly related to neurological laws. The classical approaches to reduction such as bridge law reduction, functional reduction and interpretation mappings do not explicitly address this context-dependency. In this paper it is shown how these reduction approaches can be refined to incorporate the context-dependency. It is shown how the context-dependent reduction approaches obtained make explicit in which sense laws or regularities in a cognitive theory on the one hand relate to neurological laws and on the other hand to specific makeups.
منابع مشابه
On the use of reduction relations to relate different types of agent models
This paper focuses on relationships between agent models and their physical realisations. Approaches on reduction from philosophical literature are analysed in a formalised manner, and extended by incorporating context-dependency w.r.t. specific makeups for their realisations. It is shown how these context-dependent reduction approaches can be translated into each other and how they can be appl...
متن کاملVerifying Context-Dependent Reduction Relations for Knowledge Specifications
Knowledge can be specified at different levels of conceptualisation or abstraction. In this paper, lessons learned on the philosophical foundations of cognitive science are discussed, with a focus on how the relationships of cognitive theories with specific underlying (physical/biological) makeups can be dealt with. It is discussed how these results can be applied to relate different types of k...
متن کاملColor Relationalism∗
Color relationalism is the view that colors are constituted in terms of relations to perceiving subjects and perceptual circumstances. It may be useful to compare this proposal about color against less controversial relationalist views about other properties. Relationalism about being a teacher is the (plausible) view that things bear the latter property not by virtue of their intrinsic makeups...
متن کاملRelating Knowledge Specifications by Reduction Mappings
Knowledge can be specified at different levels of conceptualisation or abstraction. In this paper, lessons learned on the philosophical foundations of cognitive science are discussed, with a focus on how the relationships of cognitive theories with specific underlying (physical/biological) makeups can be dealt with. It is discussed how these results can be applied to relate different types of k...
متن کاملپیوندهای حقوق عمومی و حقوق مالکیت ادبی و هنری: درآمدی بر مبانی نظری
Law is a set of rules and regulations governing the human social relations that its main task is establishing order and justice in these relations. Obviously, in this regard, the mere existence of rules without creating a dynamic and purposeful structure that provides the possibility of implementing rules will not be enough. So resourceful legislators always try to predict appropriate and ef...
متن کامل