A Grammar of Projections
نویسنده
چکیده
A sequence of nodes in a syntax tree, each the head of the next, is usually called a projection path, or simply a projection. Projections in this sense are fairly basic phrase-structural entities, though hardly of central importance in most accounts. There are a few exceptions. For example, varieties of projection that I called c-projection and s-projection were significant in my earlier work on the grammar of function words, and the distinction was further developed by Grimshaw under the rubric extended projections. And in quite a different direction, Kayne proposed g-projections to account for constraints on long-distance dependencies. Pesetsky, inspired by Kayne’s g-projections, proposed using paths as the basis for an account of locality; and his paths, in turn, are reminiscent of the feature-passing paths that figure prominently in intuitive accounts of attribute-value grammars. If there is more to this train of precedent than just free association and coincidences of terminology, it suggests that an account of both constituent structure and long-distance dependencies might be based on a single notion of projection. I would like to propose such an approach in the present work. As a point of departure, let me make another set of free associations, not obviously related to the first. Traditionally, there have been two broad approaches to phrase structure: immediate-constituent analysis and dependency analysis. American structuralists mostly assumed immediate-constituent analysis in preference to dependency analysis, and that prejudice was inherited by Chomsky and transformational grammar. But as transformational grammar has evolved, it has assigned an ever more central role to dependency concepts. Whereas dominance is the primitive structural relation in immediate-constituent analysis, government is the fundamental structural relation in dependency grammar. At least since the point at which the Extended Standard Theory evolved into Government-Binding Theory (GB), government has come to play a central role in Chomsky’s work. (Some related notions had a prominent place in the theory much earlier, including headship and command—the latter being definable as the transitive closure of government.) I think it is not far from the mark to say that GB reconstructs dependency structures as defined terms, atop an immediate-constituency substrate. And with the more recent introduction of ‘bare phrase structure’ [?], Chomsky’s phrase structures have all but abandoned the immediate-constituent substrate, and become nearly pure, if somewhat idiosyncratic, dependency stemmas. But let us return now to the relation between dependency structure and constituent structure, and the question of what it has to do with projections. There is something rather unsatisfying about the opportunistic mixture of constituent structure and dependency structure in GB. Constituent grammars (i.e.,
منابع مشابه
Level of Grammatical Proficiency and Acquisition of Functional Projections: The case of Iranian learners of English language
Unlike Lexical Projections, Functional Projections (Extended Projections) are more of an ‘abstract’ in nature. Therefore, Functional Projections seem to be acquired later than Lexical Projections by the L2 learners. The present study investigates Iranian L2 learners’ acquisition of English Extended Projections taking into account their level of grammatical proficiency. Specifically, the aim is ...
متن کاملThe Role of Explicit Grammar in Language Teaching
The debate on grammar in second language acquisition: past, present, and future, is a well written summary of both explicit and implicit grammar instruction in second language acquisition from past to present and with future projections. The thesis holds that explicit grammar instruction plays a very important role in foreign language learning and teaching and argues that English education in C...
متن کاملm-Projections involving Minkowski inverse and range symmetric property in Minkowski space
In this paper we study the impact of Minkowski metric matrix on a projection in the Minkowski Space M along with their basic algebraic and geometric properties.The relation between the m-projections and the Minkowski inverse of a matrix A in the minkowski space M is derived. In the remaining portion commutativity of Minkowski inverse in Minkowski Space M is analyzed in terms of m-projections as...
متن کاملInductive vs. Deductive Grammar Instruction and the Grammatical Performance of EFL Learners
Learning a foreign language offers a great challenge to students since it involves learning different skills and subskills. Quite a few number of researches have been done so far on the relationship between gender and learning a foreign language. On the other hand, two major approaches in teaching grammar have been offered by language experts, inductive and deductive. The present study examines...
متن کاملThe Role of Textual vs. Compound Input Enhancement in Developing Grammar Ability
The present study investigated comparatively the impact of two types of input enhancement (i.e. textual vs. compound enhancement) on developing grammar ability in Iranian EFL setting. Sixty-five female secondary high school students were selected as a homogenous sample out of about a 100-member population based on Nelson language proficiency test. Then, their grammar ability was measured based ...
متن کاملA model based, anatomy dependent method for ultra-fast creation of primary SPECT projections
Introduction: Monte Carlo (MC) is the most common method for simulating virtual SPECT projections. It is useful for optimizing procedures, evaluating correction algorithms and more recently image reconstruction as a forward projector in iterative algorithms; however, the main drawback of MC is its long run time. We introduced a model based method considering the eff...
متن کامل