Interfering with Nomological Necessity
ثبت نشده
چکیده
David Armstrong’s law-maker, nomological necessity (N), is a second order relational universal that holds between state of affairs types, e.g., N(F, G). With only a small proviso, nomological necessity is supposed to instantiate as the causation of its second relatum, G, whenever its first relatum, F, instantiates. — In this paper, I will show that there is some friction within this theory when we consider that causal processes can be prevented and interfered with. The above mentioned proviso is supposed to handle these case but, so I argue, it fails to do so. — The critique here presented generalises to any theory of lawhood that utilises a kind of necessitation as lawmaker. Thus, Armstrong’s case can serve as a sample for all such theories. — Plausible means of resolving the difficulties will be presented.
منابع مشابه
Establishing Nomological Networks for Behavioral Science: a Natural Language Processing Based Approach
As the accumulated research base of the behavioral sciences have grown, the amount of actual knowledge discovery has not kept pace as evidenced byan increasing number of disconnected theories and and the related problem of construct proliferation. Therefore, integrating social and behavioral sciences across research areas or even disciplines in a meaningful way is imperative. Despite the inform...
متن کاملOn Nomological Validity and Auxiliary Assumptions: The Importance of Simultaneously Testing Effects in Social Cognitive Theories Applied to Health Behavior and Some Guidelines
Tests of social cognitive theories provide informative data on the factors that relate to health behavior, and the processes and mechanisms involved. In the present article, we contend that tests of social cognitive theories should adhere to the principles of nomological validity, defined as the degree to which predictions in a formal theoretical network are confirmed. We highlight the importan...
متن کاملA New Approach to Testing Nomological Validity and Its Application to a Second-Order Measurement Model of Trust
Research Article Liping Liu The University of Akron [email protected] Chan Li The University of Pittsburgh [email protected] Dan Zhu Iowa State University [email protected] This paper examines the concept of the nomological validity of secondand/or higher-order measurement models. It also proposes a new approach that consists of measuring two validity indices — predictive and mediating efficiencies...
متن کاملEstablishing Nomological Networks for Behavioral Science: a Natural Language Processing Based Approach
As the accumulated research base of the behavioral sciences have grown, the amount of actual knowledge discovery has not kept pace as evidenced by an increasing number of disconnected theories and the related problem of construct proliferation. Therefore, integrating social and behavioral sciences across research areas or even disciplines in a meaningful way is imperative. Despite the informati...
متن کاملTracking Behavioral Construct Use through Citations: A Relation Extraction Approach
During the past few decades, social and behavioral sciences experienced a proliferation of vibrant research communities, leading to a rapid accumulation of theories, articles, and constructs (Lee et al. 2004; Straker 2008). Many efforts have been dedicated to exploration and integration of this large network of behavioral research data. For example, the inter-nomological network, a construct se...
متن کامل