Deference and Essentialism in the Categorization of Chemical Kinds
نویسنده
چکیده
Psychological essentialism has been subject to much debate. Yet a key implication – that people should defer to experts in categorizing natural kinds – has not been widely examined. Three experiments examine deference in the categorization of chemical kinds. The first establishes borderline cases used in the second and third. These latter show limited deference to experts, and some deference to non-experts. These data are consistent with a perspectival framework for concepts in which categorization is sometimes based on micro-structural properties and sometimes on appearance and function.
منابع مشابه
Deference in Categorisation: Evidence for Essentialism?
Many studies appear to show that categorization conforms to psychological essentialism (e.g., Gelman & Wellman, 1991). However, key implications of essentialism have not been scrutinized. These are that people’s categorizations should shift as their knowledge of micro-structural properties shift, and that people should defer in their categorizations to appropriate experts. Three studies are rep...
متن کاملCategorisation, Deference and Cognitive Style
Despite the importance of psychological essentialism as an account of categorisation, it is unclear what import findings of individual difference have. The present study is designed to investigate individual differences in relation to deference, a key indicator of essentialist thought. This replicates previous findings of individual differences in deference, and demonstrates a strong associatio...
متن کاملDifferences in Deference: Essences and Insights
If people have essentialist beliefs about natural kinds, it follows that when an entity’s identity is uncertain, we should defer to experts knowledgeable about its hidden inner nature. In two experiments we presented students and lay adults with scenarios involving ambiguous-looking natural kinds, artifacts, and hybrid animal-artifacts and examined whether they would choose to defer to an exper...
متن کاملOrigins of Essentialism 1 on the Functional Origins of Essentialism
This essay examines the proposal that psychological essentialism results from a history of natural selection acting on human representation and inference systems. It has been argued that the features that distinguish essentialist representational systems are especially well suited for representing natural kinds. If the evolved function of essentialism is to exploit the rich inductive potential ...
متن کاملCategorisation of Sexual Orientation: a Test of Essentialism
Psychological essentialism is an important strand of theorising within the study of categorisation, according to which people believe, and act as if, category membership is determined by the possession of an essence. Many authors have developed this position by arguing that people believe and behave as if essentialism is true of social categories. This paper reports the results of a study inves...
متن کامل