Kicking calculators: Contribution of embodied representations to sentence comprehension
نویسندگان
چکیده
Evocation of motor representations during sentence comprehension was examined by training subjects to make a hand action in response to a visual cue while listening to a sentence. Sentences referred to manipulable objects that were either related or unrelated to the cued action. Related actions pertained either to the function of the object or to its volumetric properties (e.g., shape). The results demonstrate priming of hand actions even though the sentences referred to non-manual interactions with manipulable objects. When sentences described an attentional interaction (looking at the calculator), only functional actions were primed. Sentences describing a non-manual physical interaction (kicking the calculator) primed volumetric as well as functional actions. We describe how seemingly irrelevant motor representations can play a role in constructing sentence meaning. 2008 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. There is mounting evidence that the sensory-motor system is intimately involved in conceptual operations (Barsalou, 1999; Gallese & Lakoff, 2005; Glenberg, 1997; Wilson, 2002). In some respects this idea is not so counterintuitive. For example, we can answer questions using our ‘‘mind’s eye” (e.g., Would this couch look good in our living room?). Research has also demonstrated, however, that we use other sensory-motor imagery, including our ‘‘mind’s hands”, and we do so in a covert and involuntary fashion. For example, Klatzky, Pellegrino, McCloskey, and Doherty (1989) found that judgment of the sensibility of a sentence was facilitated by performing a relevant hand action in advance. Glenberg and Kaschak (2002) had subjects judge the sensibility of sentences by pressing one of two buttons, to indicate sensible, vs. non-sensible. One of the buttons re. All rights reserved. ts from the Natural
منابع مشابه
Embodied sentence comprehension 1 EMBODIED SENTENCE COMPREHENSION
ions are being discussed in other chapters in this book (Barsalou & WiemerHastings, this volume; Gibbs, this volume; Prinz, this volume). 6.0 Conclusion and outlook We started this chapter by comparing two perspectives on cognition in general and on language comprehension in particular. According to the traditional perspective, language comprehension involves the activation and integration of d...
متن کاملColour and Stability in Embodied Representations
Traditional views of cognition have assumed that thought involves the representation and manipulation of discrete, amodal symbols, while embodied theories of cognition hold that thought is grounded in the same neural systems that govern sensation, perception and action. This paper examines whether implicit perceptual information on object colour is represented during sentence comprehension even...
متن کاملAction-Sentence Compatibility: The Role of Action Effects and Timing
Research on embodied approaches to language comprehension suggests that we understand linguistic descriptions of actions by mentally simulating these actions. Evidence is provided by the action-sentence compatibility effect (ACE) which shows that sensibility judgments for sentences are faster when the direction of the described action matches the response direction. In two experiments, we inves...
متن کاملRepresenting object colour in language comprehension q Louise Connell
Embodied theories of cognition hold that mentally representing something red engages the neural subsystems that respond to environmental perception of that colour. This paper examines whether implicit perceptual information on object colour is represented during sentence comprehension even though doing so does not necessarily facilitate task performance. After reading a sentence that implied a ...
متن کاملTo appear in Brain and Language Situated sentence processing : The coordinated interplay account and a neurobehavioral model ∗
Empirical evidence demonstrating that sentence meaning is rapidly reconciled with the visual environment has been broadly construed as supporting the seamless interaction of visual and linguistic representations during situated comprehension. Based on recent behavioral and neuroscientific findings, however, we argue for the more deeply rooted coordination of the mechanisms underlying visual and...
متن کامل