The need for feminist intersectionality in digital health

Digital health, including the use of mobile health apps, telemedicine, and data analytics to improve systems, has surged during COVID-19 pandemic. The social economic fallout from further exacerbated gender inequities, through increased domestic violence against women, soaring unemployment rates in unpaid familial care taken up by women—all factors that can worsen women's health. bolster equity access care, empowerment one's own data, reduced burden work. Yet, digital is rarely designed a perspective. In this Viewpoint, we show because lower exclusion app design, imbalance leadership, harmful stereotypes, disadvantaging women—especially women with racial or ethnic minority backgrounds. Tackling health's inequities more crucial than ever. We explain our feminist intersectionality framework tackle provide recommendations for future research. Telemedicine boomed pandemic, largest increases (>109%) occuring between March, 2020, April 7, behavioural appointments (eg, psychotherapy, psychiatry) remote consultations chronic illnesses.1Uscher-Pines L Thompson J Taylor P et al.where virtual was already reality: experiences nationwide telehealth service provider pandemic.J Med Internet Res. 2020; 22e22727Crossref PubMed Scopus (3) Google Scholar A scoping review identified almost 250 public applications—30% using artificial intelligence detect infections, develop novel treatments, continue regular care.2Gunasekeran DV Tseng RMWW Tham Y-C Wong TY Applications responses COVID-19: systematic intelligence, related technologies.NPJ Digit Med. 2021; 4: 40Crossref (26) Finally, venture funding sector 66% 2020 compared 2019.3Roth M ignites investment activity.https://www.healthleadersmedia.com/innovation/covid-19-ignites-digital-health-investment-activityDate: Jan 11, 2021Date accessed: March 1, 2021Google UN argues policy report reallocation priorities sexual reproductive services, adversely affects health.4UNPolicy brief: impact on women.https://www.unwomen.org/-/media/headquarters/attachments/sections/library/publications/2020/policy-brief-the-impact-of-COVID-19-on-women-en.pdfDate: 9, 2020Date February 20, reduce face-to-face barriers endure men: childcare, household chores, inadequate finances, time.5Power K pandemic families.Sustain Sci, Pract Policy. 16: 67-73Crossref (236) empower their up-to-date information. relieve high workload status health-care workers (who are mostly female [86%] low-income colour [51%]),6Scales Altman Campbell S It's time care: detailed profile America's direct workforce.http://phinational.org/resource/its-time-to-care-a-detailed-profile-of-americas-direct-care-workforce/Date: apps monitoring patients at home, coordinating supporting older relatives. before applications have been perspective focus fairness distribution different needs genders.7Crawford Serhal E innovation curve cannot reinforce gradient health.J 22e19361Crossref (83) why treating unfairly, especially examples stereotypes. high-income countries, solutions still niche area, marginalised groups such as minorities low-incomes under-represented.8Sarkar U Gourley GI Lyles CR al.Usability commercially available diverse patients.J Gen Intern 2016; 31: 1417-1426Crossref (123) Overall, tackling how it benefit illustrate issues three levels: users, tools, leadership. offer bias intersectional framework. Intersectional feminism theoretical helps examine intersects other identities race ethnicity, socioeconomic status, sexuality, disability) result marginalisation, disadvantage, poorer outcomes.9Couto MT Oliveira Ed Separavich MAA Luiz OdC field health: narrative theoretical-methodological literature.Salud Colect. 2019; 15e1994Crossref (7) one theory within family approaches, which originated theories Black, Indigenous, queer feminism.10Sharma Applying medical education.Lancet. 393: 570-578Summary Full Text PDF (28) Intersectionality analyses highlight important differences population based gender, accessing receiving services.11Kapilashrami Hankivsky O matters global health.Lancet. 2018; 391: 2589-2591Summary Women often portrayed homogeneous group, yet multiple intersecting put some higher risk worse outcomes women. Owing spend fewer years good despite living longer men.12Gulati G Kelly BD Domestic pandemic: what role psychiatry?.Int Law Psychiatry. 71101594Crossref (32) even White USA, incidence diseases cervical cancer,13National Center Health StatisticsCrude percentages cancer aged 18 over, United States, 2015–2018. National Interview Survey.https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nhis/ADULTS/www/index.htmDate June 24, pregnancy-related deaths complications,14Petersen EE Davis NL Goodman D al.Racial/ethnic disparities deaths—United 2007–2016.MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 68: 762-765Crossref (135) diabetes.15Britton LE Hussey JM Crandell JL Berry DC Brooks Bryant AG Racial/ethnic diabetes diagnosis glycemic control among age.J Womens (Larchmt). 27: 1271-1277Crossref (25) Reasons these rooted structural racism.9Couto As Kapilashrami Hankivsky16Kapilashrami (69) wrote Lancet 2018: “a [W]hite woman group might be penalised her class when but relative advantage over [B]lack woman”. differently situated economic, social, political worlds likely experience racism, poverty, exclusion, counterparts.17Baciu Negussie Y Geller al.Communities action: pathways equity—the root causes inequity.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK425845/Date: 2017Date January If reform efforts (which include innovations) undertaken behalf neglect fact, less met racially privileged women.18Crenshaw Mapping margins: intersectionality, identity politics, color.Stanford Rev. 1991; 43: 1241-1299Crossref Along violence,17Baciu reasons physician bias,19Hall WJ Chapman MV Lee KM al.Implicit racial/ethnic professionals its influence outcomes: review.Am Public Health. 2015; 105: e60-e76Crossref (681) mistrust resulting past experiments.20Patel Forced sterilization discrimination.Public 2017; 38: 15Crossref (21) overlooked clinical medicine research evaluating outcomes. should equity. viewed an lens, they both depend not only also like geographical location. dependency throughout Viewpoint. Although inequity problem, analysis countries. starting point conversation about need addressed eliminate disparities. countries men tools.21Rising CJ Jensen RE Moser RP Oh Characterizing US patterns behavioral tracking: Cancer Institute's Information Trends Survey data.J 22e16299Crossref (9) However, majority tools do address priorities.22Nwolise CH Carey N Shawe Preconception education diabetes: conventional interventions.J 18: e291Crossref (13) Scholar, 23Lupton Maslen How technologies qualitative interview study.J 21e11481Crossref (31) According Rock Health,24Sandhu Gambon Stotz C Zweig Evans B Femtech expansive—it's start such.https://rockhealth.com/femtech-is-expansive-its-time-to-start-treating-it-as-such/Date: Aug 3, 2020Google just 3% commercial capitalist since 2011 focused Furthermore, gaps provision persist counterparts. For example, Black participate pregnancy services often,25Nijagal Patel al.Using human centered design identify opportunities reducing perinatal care.BMC Serv (published online 13, 2021.) (preprint).https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-138912/v1Crossref (1) mortality rate infants non-Hispanic remaining highest USA.26Ely DM Driscoll AK Infant period linked birth/infant death file.Natl Vital Stat 69: 1-18Google Hispanic Latina under-represented interventions physical activity,27Joseph Keller Adams MA Ainsworth BE Print versus culturally-relevant Facebook text message delivered intervention promote activity African American women: randomized pilot trial.BMC 15: 30Crossref (81) although least physically active women.28Blackwell DL Villarroel Summary statistics: Survey, 2017—table A-4a. Age-adjusted (with standard errors) selected conditions adults characteristics: 2017.https://ftp.cdc.gov/pub/Health_Statistics/NCHS/NHIS/SHS/2017_SHS_Table_A-4.pdfDate: 2018Date enrol sexually transmitted often, having diseases.29González SK Grov Recruiting young color into RCT targeting Lessons learned implications applied technology research.J Am Coll 28.)https://doi.org/10.1080/07448481.2020.1746663Crossref (2) Lower to, from, harm children relatives, whom responsible for.30Gann Transforming lives: combating inequality.IFLA J. 45: 187-198Crossref relate uptake effectiveness remains largely unexamined. uncommon. around 90% depression studies ClinicalTrials.gov recruiting male participants, 1% gender.31Weinberger AH McKee SA Mazure CM Inclusion gender-specific trials treatments depression.J 2010; 19: 1727-1732Crossref (33) Even analyses.32Bauer GR Incorporating 2ealth methodology: challenges potential advance equity.Soc Sci 2014; 110: 10-17Crossref (549) will surge if inequalities remain unattended to. pose security risks, intersect axes status. collecting personal place users intimate partner violence,33Bacchus LJ Reiss Church programs adequately considering risk?.Glob Pract. 7: 507-514Crossref experienced Asian American, multi-race women.34Stockman JK Hayashi H JC Intimate women.J 24: 62-79Crossref (117) Network Ending Violence compiled safety considerations survivors abuse keep safe.32Bauer Abusers who victims' phones monitor location, collects, install spyware.33Bacchus Sensitive instance help violence, spur instead alleviate assault, abusers find phones.33Bacchus research,35Aguilera Figueroa CA Hernandez-Ramos R al.mHealth machine learning increase depression: trial protocol DIAMANTE Study.BMJ Open. 10e034723Crossref (11) participants undocumented immigration mistrusted collect sensitive Global Positioning System app's breached location exposed, person deportation. Thus, endanger breaches others. Many gendered language design. mixed-method symbols, colours, language, found most were neutral, had stereotypically designs, pink hearts, flowers.36Foxton Chateau norms reconstructed store ecologies visual interfaces?. University Amsterdam, 1-9Google Fitness boasted strength muscles, whereas thinness femininity. Also, ignored user diversity, depicting White, thin, young, middle-class women.37Doshi MJ Barbies, goddesses, entrepreneurs: discourses embodiment apps.Womens Stud Commun. 41: 183-203Crossref topics gendered. became aware text-messaging study university students San Francisco Bay Area USA.38Figueroa Chakraborty Modiri al.Daily motivational text-messages students: results micro-randomized trial.Ann Behav 19.)https://doi.org/10.1093/abm/kaab028Crossref Our messages included exercise make you attractive Several expressed dislike messages, felt pressured meet societal expectations. pressure adhere beauty standards could younger individuals, adolescents students, suffer eating disorders compulsive-exercise disorders.39Rich Gender, age: postfeminism pedagogical possibilities.Sport Educ Soc. 23: 736-747Crossref (22) Gender stereotypes minorities. excluding pre-pregnancy associated infant USA.40Mackert Guadagno Donovan Whitten Including prenatal e-health birth outcomes.Telemed 21: 207-212Crossref (14) Because biases, there few parenting fathers, male-oriented early parenthood tend assume uneducated uninterested caring infants, partners.40Mackert 41Thomas GM Lupton Pedersen ‘The appy happy pappy’: expectant fatherhood apps.J Gend Stud. 759-770Crossref Masculinity don't depression) lead mental seeking, via technology,42Smail-Crevier Powers Noel Wang Health-related internet usage feature preference e-mental 21e11224Crossref thereby men, triple suicide USA Canada.43Sher Suicide men.J Clin 76: e371-e372Crossref failure distinguish biological sex punishes people deemed behave according incorrectly, particularly harms trans, non-binary, intersex people.44Morgenroth T Ryan MK effects trouble: integrative perpetuation disruption gender/sex binary.Perspect Psychol Sci. May 6.)https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691620902442Crossref (19) affect dynamics, influenced income, culture, education. advise stress relief might, alleviating distress, spark guilt failing working children. Area,35Aguilera saw several asked partners them video-conferencing software interview, configure app. Asking spouse child tech-support trigger shame strain relationships, adult responsibilities. value, need, ability connect rely probably varies widely various intersections identities. researchers typically overlook whether mechanisms participants' surroundings vice versa. Dangerous biases sneak algorithms used decision making. UK Service's Babylon app, released 2017, probability self-reported symptoms. advised course contact doctor, visit emergency room, no action. smoker 59 symptoms heart attack (ie, chest pain, shortness breath, anxiety) received panic attack, same background informed possibility attack.45Trendall concerns raised GP app.https://www.publictechnology.net/articles/features/gender-bias-concerns-raised-over-gp-appDate: Sept 2019Date October affected cardiovascular disease earlier awareness leading cause death.46Kalinowski JY Spruill TM Why black disease?.Circulation. 139: 1003-1004Crossref (8) Algorithm terms ethnicity reported. algorithm recommended needed basis costs, erroneously assigned requirements being considerably sicker thus needing extra care.47Obermeyer Z Vogeli Mullainathan Dissecting manage populations.Science. 366: 447-453Crossref (621) backgrounds decades,48Feldman Ammar W Lo Trepman van Zuylen Etzioni Quantifying scale automated extraction.JAMA Netw 2e196700Crossref (35) reflect Individuals non-binary categories did searches electronic databases search engines gauge extent individuals developed, non-conforming, genderqueer, genderfluid, transgender, spectrum), medicine, research), eHealth, mHealth, intervention, app). line studies,49Vandelanotte Müller AM Short CE al.Past, present, eHealth mHealth dietary behaviors.J Nutr Behav. 48 (28.e211): 219Summary (189) unable many articles all domains. absence populations ineffective groups, data. 50% workforce female, gap leadership persists, wider fields. 12·2% funds held 10% chief executive officer positions.50Rock HealthDiversity annual report.https://rockhealth.com/reports/diversity-in-digital-health-2020-annual-report/Date: December 2019 European survey51HIMSS EuropeWomen IT survey 2019.https://www.himss.eu/communities/women-health-it-communityDate: employed companies paid excluded making men. struggle workloads receive recognition public-speaking opportunities), peers.51HIMSS greater under-representation. led venture-backed those pronounced women.52Denend McCutcheon Regan Sainz Yock Azagury Analysis perceptions technology: call action.Ann Biomed Eng. 48: 1573-1586Crossref rise roles, face unequal treatment. Men differ opinions workforce. believe tech equal, contrast, shut out