Improper priors and improper posteriors
نویسندگان
چکیده
What is a good prior? Actual prior knowledge should be used, but for complex models this often not easily available. The can in the form of symmetry assumptions, and then choice will typically an improper prior. Also more generally, it quite common to choose priors. Motivated by we consider theoretical framework statistics that includes both priors posteriors. Knowledge represented possibly unbounded measure with interpretation as explained Rényi 1955. main mathematical result here constructive proof existence transformation from posterior knowledge. always exists uniquely defined prior, observed data, statistical model. is, be, extension conventional Bayesian inference axioms Kolmogorov. It since novel construction valid also when replacing Kolmogorov conditional probability space. A concrete case based on Markov Chain Monte Carlo simulations data different species tropical butterflies illustrate may appear naturally useful. theory exemplified elementary examples.
منابع مشابه
Improper Priors Are Not Improper
It is well known that improper priors in Bayesian statistics may lead to proper posterior distributions and useful inference procedures. This motivates us to give an elementary introduction to a theoretical frame for statistics that includes improper priors. Axioms that allow improper priors are given by a relaxed version of Kolmogorov’s formulation of probability theory. The theory of conditio...
متن کاملBayes Theorem for Improper Priors
Improper priors are used frequently, but often formally and without reference to a sound theoretical basis. A consequence is the occurrence of seemingly paradoxical results. The most famous example is perhaps given by the marginalization paradoxes presented by Stone and Dawid (1972). It is demonstrated here that the seemingly paradoxical results are removed by a more careful formulation of the ...
متن کاملProper Posteriors from Improper Priors for an Unidentified Errors-in-variables Model
The problem considered is inference in a simple errors-in-variables model where consistent estimation is impossible without introducing additional exact prior information. The probabilistic prior information required for Bayesian analysis is found to be surprisingly light: despite the model's lack of identification a proper posterior is guaranteed for any bounded prior density, including those ...
متن کاملPropriety of Posteriors with Improper Priors in Hierarchical Linear Mixed Models
This paper examines necessary and sufficient conditions for the propriety of the posterior distribution in hierarchical linear mixed effects models for a collection of improper prior distributions. In addition to the flat prior for the fixed effects, the collection includes various limiting forms of the invariant gamma distribution for the variance components, including cases considered previou...
متن کاملThe marginalization paradox does not imply inconsistency for improper priors
The marginalization paradox involves a disagreement between two Bayesians who use two different procedures for calculating a posterior in the presence of an improper prior. We show that the argument used to justify the procedure of one of the Bayesians is inapplicable. There is therefore no reason to expect agreement, no paradox, and no evidence that improper priors are inherently inconsistent....
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Scandinavian Journal of Statistics
سال: 2021
ISSN: ['0303-6898', '1467-9469']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/sjos.12550