Evil is not evidence

Abstract The article aims to show that, if S5 is the logic of metaphysical necessity, then no state affairs in any possible world constitutes non-trivial evidence for or against existence traditional God. There might well be states some worlds describing extraordinary goods and evils, but it false that these constitute (non-trivial) epistemological consequences philosophical theology assuming S4 K σρ necessity are equally untenable. guarantees God does not exist there slightest And survive loss acquisition essential property at all.