I take up the four issues considered by Johnson-Laird, Byrne and Girotto in their reply to Politzer (2007). Based on the conceptual clarification which they adduce, it seems that the disagreement can be settled about the first one (truth functionality) and can be attenuated about the second one (the paradoxes of material implication). However, I maintain and refine my criticisms on the last two...

Abstract This is a rare presentation of an impacted gallstone leading to ileovaginal fistula. A 76-year old female presented with 4 week history faecal vaginal discharge and weight loss on background endometrial cancer treated chemotherapy radiotherapy 9 years ago. She was initially investigated pelvc MRI which showed collection in the stump. further abdominal pelvic CT scan revealed cholecysto...