A CRITICISM AND REVIEW OF THE RATE OF CONGRUENCE BETWEEN THE ENTRY SATANIC VERSESIN LEIDEN’S EBCYCLOPEDIA AND SUNNI SOURCES

Authors

  • Farzi , Maryam
  • Hemami, Abbas
Abstract:

The entry Satanic Verseshas been written by one of the Orientalists called Shahab Ahmad and published in Leiden’s the Encyclopedia of the Quran. Referring to Sunni works of interpretation and narrative sources, The author of this article probes into the history of the Myth of Gharaniq. Mentioning the names and namers of this current, Shahab Ahmadrefers to the Quranic verses and interpretive texts in his article and presents some reports of the analyzedsources, as well as a summary of their evaluations. He ultimately depicts its reflection in contemporary times and in Muslim sources, while using the infallibility correspondence and giving an extensive account of the issue, the author delineates that the reality ofthe Myth of Gharaniqis different from what has been reported about it.  As for the sources of the article, Shahab Ahmad refers to the works of interpretations of such commentators as Tabari, Ibn Kathir, Ibn ‘Arabi, Abu HayyanFakhral-Razi, al-Jalalin, etc. Works of interpretations bearing and repudiating doubt are observed in his bibliography, and, though paradoxically,he attemptsto reflect the views of both groups. This article criticizes and reviews the aforementioned entry with the approach that the study of the views of Orientalists in the field of religious teachings, especially the Quranic issues related to the true prophets, to a certain extent, exposes Muslimsto the intellectual atmosphere and motives of non-Muslim scholars. This article further attempts to analyze and review the observations of the author and the rate of congruencebetween theoutlooksincluded in the entry and Sunni sources. Finally, following careful scrutiny of the document and the overall content of the resources utilized in the entry andreferring to the Quran, narrations, and rational axioms, the justifications of the narrators of the reports are scrutinized and analyzed.

Upgrade to premium to download articles

Sign up to access the full text

Already have an account?login

similar resources

on translation of phatic communion and socio-cultural relationships between the characters of the novels

phatic communion is a cultural concept which differs across cultures. according to hofstede (2001), the u.s. tends to have individualistic culture; however, asian countries tend to have collectivistic cultures. these cultures view phatic communion differently. in individualistic cultures like u.s., phatic communion reflects speakers’ socio-cultural relationships in conversations. to see whether...

15 صفحه اول

on the relationship between using discourse markers and the quality of expository and argumentative academic writing of iranian english majors

the aim of the present study was to investigate the frequency and the type of discourse markers used in the argumentative and expository writings of iranian efl learners and the differences between these text features in the two essay genres. the study also aimed at examining the influence of the use of discourse markers on the participants’ writing quality. to this end the discourse markers us...

15 صفحه اول

the relationship between academic self-concept and academic achievement in english and general subjects of the students of high school

according to research, academic self-concept and academic achievement are mutually interdependent. in the present study, the aim was to determine the relationship between the academic self-concept and the academic achievement of students in english as a foreign language and general subjects. the participants were 320 students studying in 4th grade of high school in three cities of noor, nowshah...

the relationship between learners critical thinking ability and their performance in the reading sections of the tofel and ielts test

the study reflected in this thesis aims at finding out relationships between critical thinking (ct), and the reading sections of tofel and ielts tests. the study tries to find any relationships between the ct ability of students and their performance on reading tests of tofel and academic ielts. however, no research has ever been conducted to investigate the relationship between ct and the read...

15 صفحه اول

wuthering heights and the concept of marality/a sociological study of the novel

to discuss my point, i have collected quite a number of articles, anthologies, and books about "wuthering heights" applying various ideas and theories to this fantastic story. hence, i have come to believe that gadamer and jauss are rightful when they claim that "the individaul human mind is the center and origin of all meaning," 3 that reading literature is a reader-oriented activity, that it ...

15 صفحه اول

My Resources

Save resource for easier access later

Save to my library Already added to my library

{@ msg_add @}


Journal title

volume 0  issue پاییز 98 - پیش شماره جهت الگوی مقاله (از مقالات شماره های پیشین مجلات وابسته به انجمن)

pages  0- 0

publication date 2019-12

By following a journal you will be notified via email when a new issue of this journal is published.

Keywords

No Keywords

Hosted on Doprax cloud platform doprax.com

copyright © 2015-2023